Limited tax remand upheld, but appellate review must also consider declaration form evidence and double taxation claims.

A West Bengal Taxation Tribunal note on remand procedure explains that a limited remand is proper where further examination is needed only on issues already supported by the record. The Tribunal found no illegality in restricting reconsideration to the export-sale claim, declaration forms XIV-A and penalty, but held that fairness required the appellate authority to examine documentary evidence on declaration form XIV, if produced, and to consider the plea of double taxation arising from payment under the Bihar Sales Tax Act. The limited remand was therefore upheld, with the remand directions expanded on those two points.

---

---

Issues: Whether the revisional order was justified in remanding the matter only on a limited point, and whether the Tribunal should modify the remand so that the appellate authority also considers the declaration-form claim and the plea of double taxation.

Analysis: The dispute arose from disallowance of deductions, labour charges, purchase tax, turnover tax, and penalty on the basis of alleged non-production of books and supporting materials. The appellate and revisional authorities had substantially sustained the assessment findings, while directing reconsideration only on the export-sale claim, declaration forms XIV-A, and penalty. On the record, the Tribunal found no illegality in restricting the remand to issues supported by materials already requiring further examination. At the same time, it found that fairness required the appellate authority to consider documentary evidence relating to declaration form XIV, if produced, and to examine whether the petitioner had suffered double taxation by reason of payment under the Bihar Sales Tax Act.

Conclusion: The limited remand was upheld, but the direction was modified to require consideration of declaration form XIV and the plea of double taxation in addition to the issues already remanded.

---