Duty paid scrap requirement limits exemption for unwrought lead made from duty-free cleared inputs.

Unwrought lead manufactured from scrap cleared under Notification No. 186/84 did not qualify for exemption under Notification No. 37/81 because that exemption applied only where the input was old duty paid waste or scrap, or other materials on which the requisite excise duty or additional duty had been paid. The scrap used here had been cleared free of duty for captive consumption and therefore lacked the duty paid status required by the exemption condition. A prior departmental order cited by the appellant did not change that position because it did not establish that the input satisfied the duty paid requirement. The exemption was therefore unavailable.

---

---

Issues: Whether lead unwrought manufactured from scrap cleared under Notification No. 186/84 could qualify for exemption under Notification No. 37/81 as old duty paid waste or scrap.

Analysis: Notification No. 37/81 granted exemption to unwrought lead only when produced from specified inputs, including old duty paid scrap or other materials on which appropriate duty of excise or additional duty under Section 3 of the Customs Tariff Act, 1975 had been paid. The scrap used by the appellant had itself been cleared free of duty under Notification No. 186/84 for captive consumption, and therefore it was not duty paid. On that factual basis, the scrap could not fall within the category of old duty paid scrap contemplated by Notification No. 37/81. The earlier departmental order relied upon by the appellant did not alter this conclusion because it did not establish that the scrap had the status of duty paid material so as to satisfy the exemption condition.

Conclusion: The appellant was not entitled to exemption under Notification No. 37/81, and the denial of benefit was upheld.

---