Manufactured tobacco classification turns on substantial processing, with processed tobacco dust falling under the manufactured tobacco tariff entry.

Shaheen Misri and Kokan Misri, made from tobacco dust through heating, roasting, grinding and addition of salt, were treated as manufactured tobacco because the processing altered the raw material before sale. Tariff Entry 24.04 covers other manufactured tobacco and tobacco preparations, and the presence of tobacco dust in the inputs did not prevent classification of the finished product as manufactured tobacco. On that basis, the product was held classifiable under Tariff Entry 2404.90, not under Tariff Entry 2401.90 for unmanufactured tobacco, and the lower appellate classification was upheld.

---

---

Issues: Whether Shaheen Misri and Kokan Misri, prepared from tobacco dust by heating, roasting, grinding and adding salt, were classifiable under Tariff Entry 2404.90 as manufactured tobacco or under Tariff Entry 2401.90 as unmanufactured tobacco.

Analysis: The product was subjected to processing that altered the raw tobacco dust before sale, including removal of moisture, addition of salt, roasting and grinding. Tariff Entry 24.04 covers other manufactured tobacco and tobacco preparations, and the reasoning adopted treated cut tobacco and similar processed tobacco products as falling within that entry. On that basis, tobacco dust used in the preparation did not prevent the finished product from being regarded as manufactured tobacco. The same view had also been taken in comparable appellate orders.

Conclusion: The product was correctly classifiable under Tariff Entry 2404.90 and not under Tariff Entry 2401.90; the Revenue's appeal failed.

Final Conclusion: The classification adopted by the lower appellate authority was upheld, with the result that the appeal was rejected and the assessee's classification prevailed.

Ratio Decidendi: A tobacco product subjected to substantial processing that results in a manufactured tobacco preparation falls under the tariff entry for manufactured tobacco rather than the entry for unmanufactured tobacco.

---