Modvat credit for process chemicals and rust preventives allowed where their use was integral to manufacture.

Modvat credit was held admissible on Metaquench 42, Koolkut oil 40 and Rustop because their use formed part of the manufacturing process: Metaquench 42 functioned as quench oil for tempering metal, while Koolkut 40 and Rustop prevented rust and corrosion of bearings. Denial of credit on the ground that the goods were not essential for manufacture was rejected as overlooking the technological requirement of the process. As the goods were established as used in manufacture, credit was allowed and the penalty could not be sustained, so it was set aside.

---

---

Issues: Whether Modvat credit was admissible on Metaquench 42, Koolkut oil 40 and Rustop, and whether the penalty imposed on the assessee was sustainable.

Analysis: The use of the goods was accepted as part of the manufacturing process: Metaquench 42 was used as quench oil for tempering metal, while Koolkut 40 and Rustop were used to prevent rust and corrosion of ball bearings and roller bearings. The denial of credit on the premise that the goods were not essential for manufacture was held to ignore the technological requirement of the process. In view of the established use of the goods in manufacture, the assessee was found entitled to credit. Consequentially, the penalty could not survive.

Conclusion: Modvat credit was allowed on the goods in question and the penalty was set aside.

---