2026 (11) TMI 602
X X X X Extracts X X X X
X X X X Extracts X X X X
.... "1. That the deponent, an individual having PAN - BNWPA2824A resident of 207, Durga Nagar Firozabad 283203 and is well verse with the facts of the case. 2. That the Ld Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) has passed an order under section 250 of the Act was merely uploaded on E-portal and was not served by other modes as specified under section 282 of the Act. 3. That the deponent is not techno savy, therefore the order uploaded on portal did not come to her notice. 4. That finally on 3rd March 2026, the Consultant of the deponent, on login to Income Tax Portal came to know about order dated 23.05.2025 uploaded on the Portal. 5. That the deponent was advised to file appeal before the Hon'ble Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, Agra. 6. That due to reasons mentioned above, there occurred delay in filling of appeal before the Hon'ble ITAT, Agra. 7. That the reason for delay in filing of appeal is stated above. Since, there is genuine reason for delay in filing of appeal, the same may be condone in the interest of justice. 8. It is humbly prayed to the Hon'ble member of ITAT to condone the delay in filing of appe....
X X X X Extracts X X X X
X X X X Extracts X X X X
....before the AO stated that day wise detailed list of persons whom payment is made from the money withdrawn from the bank account along with the commission earned thereon was being submitted. The assessee further submitted that the turnover of commission income was of Rs. 1,84,956/- while deposits in bank accounts are Rs. 3,69,92,943/- which is Rs 500/- per lac as per the bank account detail with party payment detail. The assessee also placed reliance on Umesh Chandra Garg vs ACIT (2004) 91TTJ 0549]. 3.2 The AO considered the above explanation of the assessee but did not accept the same. The AO noted that Firozabad is a big township area where the explanation of the assessee in cash dealing was not acceptable because the banking channels were available in Firozabad. The AO also observed that the cash had been deposited from across the country like Margaon, Hospet, Aurangabad, Imphal, Guwahati, Chatra, Vapi, Lakshmipur, Gaya etc. and the moot question was how the people from across the country got to know about the bank accounts of the assessee where the cash was required to be deposited. The AO also noted that the assessee stated that it was not possible to provide names and compl....
X X X X Extracts X X X X
X X X X Extracts X X X X
....reproduced as under: "7. In view of the facts mentioned above the following inferences are drawn. a) There prima facia appears to be no need for the outside parties to make cash deposits in assessee's accounts considering vide spread reach of internet payments, e-payments and banking facilities. These amounts can be directly deposited in the accounts of the trades as jandhan bank accounts have been opened across the country under major flagship project of the govt. b) There is no co relationship between amount deposited & withdrawn. Thus, it is not clear how the assessee makes out from whom the money is received and to whom it is to be paid. c) It is not clear whether the assessee deals with only select parties (1or 2 parties) from each city. If that being so, how do these parties make purchases - from one trader or many. If the traders are many, how does the assessee get instruction whom to pay. d) The issue of how the assessee charges her commission is also not clear. Especially in wake of the fact that 90% of the amounts received are less than Rs. 1,00,000/-. If that being does assessee maintain ledger account party wise. That bei....
X X X X Extracts X X X X
X X X X Extracts X X X X
.....1.8 Also, the careful perusal of the copy of the bank statement enclosed by her with her submissions dtd 15.5.2025 it is very evident that only cash deposits and cash withdrawals were being transacted in her bank account with no clarity/identity about the person to whom such payments were made. Thus, not only the credits even the debits in the bank account of the appellant remains unexplained by her except for mere statement. Thus, there is absolutely no evidence brought on record by the appellant to support her claim that she is into commission business playing the role of cash handler in the bangle trade between the purchaser and the seller in Firozabad. 6.1.9 Under these circumstances without submitting fool proof evidence for the nature of business engaged into by the appellant, it is not appropriate for her to simply rely on various judgements alone and seeking the relief. With due respect to all those judicial judgements relied upon by the appellant, it is noticed that in those judgements it is established that those assessee's have been engaged in the bank drafts discounting or cash collection business as it is explicitly stated in the case of Priti Agarwal Vs ....
X X X X Extracts X X X X
X X X X Extracts X X X X
....ssion the Appellant submitted the details of suppliers to whom payment was made on behalf of various persons who had deposited cash in Bank Account of the Appellant. The Id CTT(A) passed an order confirming the addition made by the Id AO 4. Because, the Ld. CIT (A) erred both in law and facts in confirming the addition of Rs. 3,69,92,943 made by Ld. AO under section 69A of the Act for alleged failure to record amount in the books of account. The Ld. CIT (A) has miserably failed to appreciate the explanation given by the Appellant regarding the modus operandi of the business explained during the course of assessment proceedings and Appellate proceeding. The addition, being wholly illegal and is liable to be deleted. 5. Because the Ld. CIT (A) has erred in law and facts to appreciate that the Id AO had accepted the business activity of the appellant and business profit disclosed in income tax return. It is settled principle of law once the business activity is established and the money deposited in bank account relates/pertains/belongs to business activity being carried on by the appellant, no addition can be made under section 69A of the Act. 6. Because, t....
X X X X Extracts X X X X
X X X X Extracts X X X X
....awals. The ld. AR also referred to the assessment order dated 30.10.2019 passed u/s. 143(3) of the Act for the immediately preceding assessment year, i.e., 2017-18 in the case of the assessee, wherein the AO in the assessment order noted that 'on perusal of the details submitted by the assessee, it is noticed that during the year under consideration the assessee enjoyed income from commission'. The assessee also relied upon various case laws as per the index, which is reproduced as under: S. No. Description Page Numbers Relevant para and page 1 Ahmedabad ITAT in ITA Number 885/Ahd/2026 Ashaben Atul Kumar Patel vs ITO. 1 to 11 Para 5, page 3, Para 13, page 5 Para 14, page 10 2 Bombay High Court in PCIT VS Alag Securities Private Ltd, 1512/2017. 12 to 21 Para 20, page 8 Para 21 page 9 3 ITAT, Mumbai Bench in ITA 2934/Mum/2024 in Jagmandri Finvest Private Ltd vs ITO, Wd 9(2)(1), Mumbai. 22 to 28 Parra 9, page 6 4 Chennai ITAT in 1539/Chny/2026 Vinayagam Balamurugan vs ITO ITO. 29 to 34 Para 11, page 5 5 Hon'ble Allahabad High Court in CIT, Gorakhpur vs Abdul Haseeb, Prop J.B. Silk 35 to 40 Page 6 7. On the othe....
X X X X Extracts X X X X
X X X X Extracts X X X X
....dited books of account and complete details establishing the identity of the buyers and sellers, the genuineness of the entire transaction remains unsubstantiated, and the transaction appears to be sham. 6.2 Where there is not a single party wise transaction detail is available to show that how much amount was utilize for purchasing any good and what commission has been charged on such transactions it cannot be simply said that the withdrawals of cash represent the same cash deposited in the bank account. There is no ledger, general account, purchase/sale bill, or any party wise, entity wise details of sale/purchase/commission received. Assessee has given only a general statement that she takes Rs. 500 per 1 lakh but which customer has paid what amount of commission is not established unless the requisite bills ledger or any documentary evidence justifying the identity of the customer or seller is given. 6.3 In the absence of any documentary evidence establishing the source of the cash deposited in the bank accounts amounting to Rs.3,69,92,943/-, it is evident that the assessee has failed to explain the nature and source of the cash deposits made during the financ....
TaxTMI