Uncorroborated electronic records cannot alone support tax additions, while unproved cash rent and stock discrepancies remain disallowed.

X X   X X   Extracts   X X   X X

Full Text of the Document

X X   X X   Extracts   X X   X X

....Uncorroborated electronic records cannot alone support additions for unexplained investments, expenditure, interest, sales or debtor balances unless independent evidence establishes their nexus with the assessee and the recorded transactions. Excel worksheets, payment sheets and electronic debtor data containing inconsistencies, without supplier or debtor verification, books, invoices, banking records or other supporting material, failed this standard; the related additions were deleted. WeChat diary figures were accepted only to the extent actually recorded, with gross profit estimated thereon, because no evidence justified applying a multiplier. Cash-rent expenditure was disallowed for want of receipts, ledger entries, landlord confirmation or payment proof, and unexplained stock investment was sustained because the stock difference remained unreconciled.....