TaxTMI 
TaxTMI 
2026 (5) TMI 585
X X X X Extracts X X X X
X X X X Extracts X X X X
....ned by the bank on 28.10.2013 for purchase of shuttering materials however on the enquiry, it was found that TIN No. was not existing apart from the authenticity of the invoices. In the Original Complaint seeking confirmation of the provisional attachment order disclosed that 10 crores sanctioned against the primary securities to the company was towards the stock and book debts as on 07.11.2014. The last stock statement submitted was for May, 2015 and transactions in CCH account ceased from 01.06.2015. The borrower was given numerous reminders and follow up but he failed to provide required stock statements and even failed to cooperate with the financial institution. It was also revealed that in collusion with the valuer, managed to inflate the valuation of the property mortgaged to the bank as collateral. Taking overall facts into consideration and after initiation of the investigation under the Prevention of Money Laundering Act, 2002 (in short 'the Act of 2002'), the provisional attachment of the property was caused and is being challenged by the appellant. Arguments of the appellant- The counsel for the appellant submits that an interim order has been passed by the Pun....
X X X X Extracts X X X X
X X X X Extracts X X X X
....o the provisional attachment has been made primarily on the ground of interim order passed by the Punjab and Haryana High Court against the predicate offence. I have gone through the interim order passed by the High Court. It has not stayed the predicate offence rather it is only a direction to the Trial Court to adjourn the matter till the next date of hearing by the High Court. Thus, argument of the learned counsel for the appellant that there is a stay against the predicate offence is far from truth. It is apart from the fact that unless the predicate offence is quashed or there is an order of discharge or acquittal, an interference in the provisional attachment order passed after applying the procedure and legally sustainable, cannot be interfered with. Thus, the first ground raised by the appellant is not made out. The learned counsel for the appellant raised the issue about coram of the Adjudicating Authority. I find that a detailed order about the coram has been passed by different High Courts taking a view favourable to the ED holding no illegality in passing of an order by one member of the Adjudicating Authority. It is however a fact that a reverse view has also been t....
X X X X Extracts X X X X
X X X X Extracts X X X X
....t, in our opinion, is tenuous. For, the definition of "proceeds of crime" is wide enough to not only refer to the property derived or obtained as a result of criminal activity relating to a scheduled offence, but also of the value of any such property. If the property is taken or held outside the country, even in such a case, the property equivalent in value held within the country or abroad can be proceeded with. The definition of "property" as in Section 2(1)(v) is equally wide enough to encompass the value of the property of proceeds of crime. Such interpretation would further the legislative intent in recovery of the proceeds of crime and vesting it in the Central Government for effective prevention of money-laundering." 3.3. The aforesaid observations made by the Supreme Court enable this Bench to re-examine the entire issue, as in the considered opinion of this Bench, the judgment passed in Seema Garg's case (supra) is no longer a good law. This Court has taken this view due to the subsequent interpretation by the Supreme Court, which has superseded the legal principles established in Seema Garg's case (supra). 3.4. It is evident that the original (u....
X X X X Extracts X X X X
X X X X Extracts X X X X
....ut the tainted properties derived or obtained directly or indirectly by any person as a result of criminal activity relating to a scheduled offence. Thereafter, the untainted properties are further divided into two parts; the first part deals with a situation where the property derived or obtained from 'proceeds of crime' is not traceable. In the aforesaid situation the competent authority is authorized to attach or confiscate any other property of accused, which is of the same value as that of the 'proceeds of crime'. The second sub-category is a result of amendment brought in 2015 and 2019 in the Act. It provides that if the property derived or obtained from the proceeds of crime has already been taken out of the Country then the property equivalent in value held within the Country or abroad can be made liable to be attached. This position has been explained by the Delhi High Court in an elaborate manner in Axis Bank's case (supra) and Prakash Industries case (supra). 3.6. It is not disputed that the Supreme Court in Vijay Madanlal Chaudhary's case (supra) was examining the scope of the '2002 Act' including definition of phrase 'procee....
X X X X Extracts X X X X
X X X X Extracts X X X X
....a) and held that the properties acquired before the alleged crime and before the enforcement of the '2002 Act' cannot be attached. 3.9. On the other hand the judgments passed in Vijay Madanlal Chaudhary's case (supra), Axis Bank's case (supra) and Prakash Industries case (supra) completely answer the question in favour of ED. 3.10. The petitioner's counsel has also heavily relied upon Pavana Dibbur's case (supra). This Bench has carefully read the aforesaid judgment. The aforementioned case involved attachment of properly falling under the category of 'direct' or 'indirect' proceeds of crime. The complaint under Section 44-45 of 2002 Act was quashed by the Supreme Court. The Bench was never called upon to analyse the contentions based upon Section 2(i)(u) of 2002 Act, whereas, in Vijay Madanlal Chaudhary's case (supra) the Court directly answered the aforesaid question. Hence, there is no substance in the first argument of learned counsel for petitioner". Earlier to the judgement referred above, this Tribunal had also passed detailed judgement on the issue in the case of Shri Sadananda Nayak Vs. Directorate of Enforce....
X X X X Extracts X X X X
X X X X Extracts X X X X
....e derived or obtained as a result of any criminal activity relatable to the scheduled offence;" 13. The perusal of the definition aforesaid shows three limbs. In between every limb word "or" has been used to divide the definition into three parts. The first part refers to the property acquired or derived directly or indirectly out of the criminal activities relating to the scheduled offence. In the first part, all those properties which are acquired directly or indirectly out of criminal activities would be termed to be the proceeds of crime. The properties can be acquired directly or indirectly with the use of proceeds of crime. The use of proceeds directly or indirectly would be relevant part to fall in first part of the definition of `proceeds of crime'. To clarify the definition, it may be illustrated. Assuming in a case of dacoit, the accused secured the money and it has been used for the purchase of property, then such a property would fall in the definition of `proceeds of crime' having been obtained out of proceeds of crime. In other case where the property was not acquired or derived by the accused himself but he passed on money out of the crime to another person ....
X X X X Extracts X X X X
X X X X Extracts X X X X
....ing the provision or making it redundant to a great extent and for this, jurisdiction does not lie with any court of law which includes even the Constitutional Court. They can declare any provision to be unconstitutional but till then there remains presumption of constitutional validity. 16. At this stage, we may refer to Para 68 of the judgment in the case of Vijay Madanlal Choudhary (supra) which is quoted hereunder. "68. It was also urged before us that the attachment of property must be equivalent in value of the proceeds of crime only if the proceeds of crime are situated outside India. This argument, in our opinion, is tenuous. For, the definition of "proceeds of crime" is wide enough to not only refer to the property derived or obtained as a result of criminal activity relating to a scheduled offence, but also of the value of any such property. If the property is taken or held outside the country, even in such a case, the property equivalent in value held within the country or abroad can be proceeded with. The definition of "property" as in Section 2(1)(v) is equally wide enough to encompass the value of the property of proceeds of crime. Such interpretatio....
X X X X Extracts X X X X
X X X X Extracts X X X X
....rmed, there must be some assessment (even if tentative one) as to the value of wrongful gain made by the specified criminal activity unless it be not possible to do so by such stage, given the peculiar features or complexities of the case. The confiscation to be eventually ordered, however, must be restricted to the value of illicit gains from the crime. For the sake of convenience, the properties covered by the second and third categories may be referred to as "the alternative attachable property" or "deemed tainted property". 17. The judgment of the Delhi High Court makes it clear that the definition of "proceeds of crime" has three limbs and in the second limb the properties of equivalent value to the proceeds obtained out of crime can be attached which may have been acquired prior to the commission of crime but it would be when proceeds of crime has been vanished and is not available. It is sought to achieve the object of the Act of 2002. 18. In the light of judgment of the Apex Court in Vijay Madanlal Choudhary (supra), we are unable to apply the judgment of Kerala High Court in the case of Satish Motilal Bidri (supra). The Ld. counsel did not refer the relev....
X X X X Extracts X X X X
X X X X Extracts X X X X
.... Judges comprising the Division Bench then proceeded to hold that even if the intent of the legislature was to include any property in the hands of a person within the ambit of the expression proceeds of crime‖, there would be no need to create three limbs of definition of proceeds of crime. xxxx 79. Regard must also be had to the fact that the legislation itself is dealing with contingencies where proceeds of crime are layered and their origins camouflaged and masked enabling the accused to project or claim it to be untainted property. The Act clearly as does Axis Bank take into consideration a situation where a person who has obtained proceeds of crime by commission of a scheduled offence has managed to ensure that a property directly or indirectly connected to criminal activity is rendered untraceable. It is to confer authority upon the Directorate to proceed further in such a situation that Section 2(1)(u) uses the expression or the value of any such property. The safeguard which stands constructed in Section 2(1)(u) in such a contingency is that in case the Directorate does proceed against any other property, it must be equivalent in value to the illega....
X X X X Extracts X X X X
X X X X Extracts X X X X
.... agree with the principles as laid down in Seema Garg as well as the subsequent decisions rendered by the Andhra Pradesh High Court in Kumar Pappu Singh Vs. Union of India and the Patna High Court in HDFC Bank Limited Vs Government of India, Ministry of Finance. 81. The Court also takes note of the position that although SLP (Crl) No. 28906/2019 is pending before the Supreme Court against the decision rendered in Axis Bank, the judgement of this Court has not been stayed or placed in abeyance. The interim order of 30 August 2019 passed in the aforesaid Special Leave Petition only requires parties to maintain status quo. Insofar as the judgement of the Punjab and Haryana High Court in Seema Garg is concerned, although SLP (C) No.14713-14715/2020 preferred against the same came to be dismissed, while doing so the Supreme Court recorded that the petition was being rejected in the peculiar facts and circumstances of the case. The dismissal of the aforesaid Special Leave Petition cannot in any case be interpreted or understood as being an affirmation of the view as expressed by the Punjab and Haryana High Court. xxxx 105. It would be pertinent to recall that p....
X X X X Extracts X X X X
X X X X Extracts X X X X
....inition of "proceeds of crime" is given interpretation by dividing it into two parts or by taking only two limbs, then it would be easy for the accused to siphon off or vanish the proceeds immediately after the commission of scheduled offence and in that case none of his properties could be attached to secure the interest of the victim till conclusion of the trial. This would not only frustrate the object of the Act of 2002, but would advance the cause of the accused to promote the crime of money laundering. The Judgment in the case of Vijay Madanlal Chaudhary (supra) is of three judges bench while the judgment in the case of Pavana Dibur (supra) is of two judges bench. The issue has otherwise been dealt with by this Tribunal in the case of FPA-PMLA-2909/CHD/2019 M/s. Besco International FZE vs. The Deputy Director Directorate of Enforcement, Chandigarh dated 31.07.2024. The relevant para of the said judgment is quoted hereunder: "It is not that only those properties which have been were derived or obtained directly or indirectly out of the crime can be attached rather in case of non-availability of the property derived or obtained directly or indirectly rather when it is ....