TaxTMI 
TaxTMI 
2021 (12) TMI 39
X X X X Extracts X X X X
X X X X Extracts X X X X
....so mean a reference to the same provision under the MPGST Act. Further, henceforth, for the purposes of this Advance Ruling, a reference to such a similar provision under the CGST or MP GST Act would be mentioned as being under the GST Act. BRIEF FACTS OF THE CASE AND SUBMISSION OF THE APPLICANTS IN THEIR APPLICATION IS AS UNDER - 3.1. The Applicant is a Public Sector Undertaking. The company is jointly owned by the Government of MP and is equally managed by Madhya Pradesh Urban Development Company Limited (MPUDCL) and Bhopal Municipal Corporation (BMC). The sole objective of Applicant is Planning and implementing the "Smart City Project" in Bhopal. 3.2. Smart City Bhopal Mission and values: The smart city mission of the Government of India seeks to address the issue of urbanization through the transformation of selected cities. The intent is to create sustainable cities that can provide a good quality life to its citizens. Bhopal has been amongst the 20 lighthouse cities with a dramatically different approach which is driven by 'Redevelopment' rather than 'Retrofitting'. 3.3 in pursuance to LAND MONETIZATION SCHEME of Smart City Mission, A RFP for Allotment of Plot on ....
X X X X Extracts X X X X
X X X X Extracts X X X X
....68 of RFP provides the details of PROJECT UTILITIES which is to be provided by the applicant in respect of said Plot. 3.7 Execution of Allotment Letter (Please 8 of RFP at Page 26) "8.1 The Allotment letter [as per the RFP Part-III] will be issued to the Allottee, after the Selected Bidder has fully complied with the terms of LolD. The Selected Bidder will be referred to as an Allottee in the Allotment letter, after BSCDCL has received the payment of First Instalment of the Sale Price, amounting to 25% (Twenty Five percent] of the sale Price within 60 (Sixty) days from the date of issuance of LolD. 8.2 Please take note that the issuance of Allotment letter does not grants or vests any ownership rights and/ or possession rights over the Plot in favour of the Allottee any manner whatsoever, and BSCDCL shall continue to have complete ownership and possession of Plot /property till entire Sale Price/ sale consideration has been paid by the Allottee to BSCDCL and a Deed of Conveyance has been executed in favour of the Allottee." 3.8 Execution of Deed of Conveyance :(Please refer 10.1 of RFP at Page 27),- "10.1 Any time after the payment of the full Sale ....
X X X X Extracts X X X X
X X X X Extracts X X X X
....uilding regulations and permissions (as amended from to time) as per MP Bhumi ViKasNiyam, 2012, Development Control Regulations (DCR) of Bhopal Smart City Development Corporation limited and any other applicable law with respect to Area Based Development (ABD) area/ the Plot, and further, the Buyer shall also fully abide by the applicable Development Plan with respect to the Plot." 3.10 The Applicant will carry out the development activities on the said plot of kind and also in the ABD area. The development activities include 24X7 water supply and power, underground utility corridor, ICT infrastructure, smart street lighting, automated solid waste system. Apart from this, Applicant will develop and maintain other infrastructure such as 45 m Wide Road (Boulevard Street). 3.11 As per REP, Consideration/Sale Price has been fixed for lumpsum basis i.e. Consolidated price for Developed Plot has been fixed. That is, no segregation into Value of Land and value of development facilities/utilities whether relating to Plotor common facilities in the Area has been made. 3.12 The Allottee (Successful Bidder), after complying with the terms and condition of the REP, Allotment Letter, L....
X X X X Extracts X X X X
X X X X Extracts X X X X
....ion on account of the value of transfer of land or undivided share of land from the total amount charged is available to the applicant? 5. DEPARTMENT'S VIEW POINT- 6. RECORD OF PERSONAL HEARING- Mr. S. Krishnan, CA on behalf of Applicant and Shri Atul Shrivastava, Dy. Commissioner, SGST Circle-1, Bhopal, Jurisdictional officer appeared virtually for personal hearing and Shri Krishnan reiterated the submissions already made in the application. Later on applicant also provided the letter issued by NagriyaVikasEvemAvasVibhag M.P by which the land which was transfer by the department to Bhopal Smart City Corporation Limited. The applicant also gave the detail of how the land costing was to be done by the Corporation. Later on the applicant also sent a letter stating that the provision relating to obtaining the completion certificate is not applicable in respect of the project being executed by the applicant, in support of his statement the applicant also included a photocopy of letter dated 03-11-2001 issued by the Municipal Corporation Bhopal to the applicant in which the corporation has stated that the completion certificate is issued under the provisions of Madhya Prades....
X X X X Extracts X X X X
X X X X Extracts X X X X
....e definition is as under:- (52) "goods" means every kind of movable property other than money and securities but includes actionable claim, growing crops, grass and things attached to or forming part of the land which are agreed to be severed before supply or under a contract of supply ; 7.4.2 The definition of Service given in Section 2(102) however seems to include land in its purview in so far as it states that services means anything other than goods. The relevant text is as under:- (102) "services" means anything other than goods, money and securities but includes activities relating to the use of money or its conversion by cash or by any other mode, from one form, currency or denomination. to another form, currency or denomination for which a separate consideration is charged; 7.4.3 This interpretation of supply of land being a supply of service seems grossly absurd and should have been hit by the Rule of Absurdity, but by virtue of Entry No. 5 in Schedule III. this absurdity seems to have been prevented. Entry No. 5 states as under:- 5. Sale of land and, subject to clause (b) of paragraph 5 of Schedule II, sale of building. Thus, Sale of L....
X X X X Extracts X X X X
X X X X Extracts X X X X
....sence of sale. 7.5.5. It has been stated in the question that the sale of the plot is after carrying out the development activities or providing amenities such as Drainage line, water line, electricity line, land levelling, and common facilities viz road and street light etc. This development work does not get transferred to the buyer of the plot of land. The development work is a common amenity, which is to be enjoyed b\ people at large who own the adjacent parcel of land as well as all such persons who have a right of way. Thus, in this case, the subject matter of sale is the land only and not the development work done. 7.5.6. Hon'ble Karnataka Appellate Tribunal in the case of Continental Builders and Developers v. State of Karnataka, 2009 (67) Kar. L. J 359 (Tri) (FB) examined the issue whether development of plots and sale, is works contract or not under Karnataka Sales Tax Act, 1957. The Tribunal had held that, "Civic amenities work done by land developer, there is no transfer of property in goods to the site purchasers either collectively or individually." 7.5.7. The development work done on the land is for the whole parcel of land and not for a given plot,....
X X X X Extracts X X X X
X X X X Extracts X X X X
....l work on the plot of land being sold is subsumed in land itself and ceases to have a separate identity. It cannot be bought and sold as something distinct and separate from the plot of land. 7.7 The term "Land" has not been defined under the GST Laws and therefore, in the absence of a definition in a statue, the meaning of land has to be construed in its popular sense. 7.7.1 Land may be qualified by its use or nature like agricultural, fallow, urban, rural, industrial, commercial or residential, but it remains land. The end result of the activity of development of land does not result in a Building or Complex. In the Trade Parlance developed land is also known as land. 7.7.2 It is no more res integra that words used in taxing statutes in respect of items should be interpreted in the way in which it is understood by people conversant with the subject matter of the statute, unless statute prescribes a specific definition. Scientific and technical meaning should not be applied but popular meaning should be applied as legislature does not suppose the merchants to be geologists, botanists or naturalists. - CCE v. Krishna Carbon Paper Co. 1988 taxmann.com 620 7.8 The questio....
X X X X Extracts X X X X
X X X X Extracts X X X X
....03 (2) until and unless declared void under Section 104 (1) of the GST Act. ============= Document 1 The Deputy Commissioner, Bhopal Circle - I, Bhopal vide letter ร ยคโขร ยคยฎร ยคยพร ยคโร ยคโข / ร ยคยฐร ยคยพร ยคโข / ร ยคโฐร ยคยชร ยคยพ / ร ยคยธร ยคยพร ยคยฎร ยคยพร ยคยจร ยฅยร ยคยฏ-1 / 2021 /597 dated 08th July 2021 submitted his comments as under:- "1 ร ยคโขร ยคยฐร ยคยฆร ยคยพร ยคยคร ยคยพ ร ยคยร ยคโขร ยคยธร ยคยฐร ยฅยร ยคยตร ยคยฟร ยคยธร ยคยชร ยฅยร ยคยฐร ยคยพร ยคยชร ยฅยร ยคยคร ยคโขร ยคยฐร ยฅยร ยคยคร ยคยพ/ร ยคยชร ยฅยร ยคยฐร ยคยฆร ยคยพร ยคยคร ยคยพร ยคโขร ยฅโกร ยคยฐร ยฅโร ยคยชร ยคยฎร ยฅโกร ยคโ ร ยคยฎร ยคยพร ยคยฒร ยคยร ยคยตร ยคโร ยคยธร ยฅโกร ยคยตร ยคยพร ยคโขร ยคยฐ ร ยคโฆร ยคยงร ยคยฟร ยคยจร ยคยฟร ยคยฏร ยคยฎร ยคโขร ยฅโก ร ยคโฆร ยคโร ยคยคร ยคยฐร ยฅยร ยคโร ยคยค ร ยคยชร ยคโร ยคลร ยฅโฌร ยคยฏร ยคยค ร ยคยนร ยฅหร ยฅยค 23ร ยคยธร ยคโขร ยฅโก ร ยคยฆร ยฅยร ยคยตร ยคยพร ยคยฐร ยคยพ ร ยคยชร ยฅยร ยคยฐร ยคยธร ยฅยร ยคยคร ยฅยร ยคยค Form GST ARA - 01 ร ยคยธร ยฅโกร ยคลร ยฅยร ยคลพร ยคยพร ยคยคร ยคยนร ยฅโนร ยคยคร ยคยพร ยคยนร ยฅหร ยคโขร ยคยฟร ยคโขร ยคยฐร ยคยฆร ยคยพร ยคยคร ยคยพร ยคยฆร ยฅยร ยคยตร ยคยพร ยคยฐร ยคยพ ร ยคยญร ยฅโร ยคยฎร ยคยฟร ยค....
X X X X Extracts X X X X
X X X X Extracts X X X X
....ร ยคโขร ยฅโกร ยคยคร ยคยพร ยคโขร ยฅโกร ยคยฒร ยคยฟร ยคยร ยคยญร ยคยตร ยคยจ/ร ยคยชร ยคยฐร ยคยฟร ยคยธร ยคยฐร ยคยจร ยคยฟร ยคยฐร ยฅยร ยคยฎร ยคยพร ยคยฃร ยคยนร ยฅโกร ยคยคร ยฅย "ร ยคยจร ยคยฟร ยคยฐร ยฅยร ยคยฎร ยคยพร ยคยฃร ยคโขร ยฅโฌ ร ยคยถร ยฅยร ยคยฐร ยฅโกร ยคยฃร ยฅโฌ" ร ยคยฎร ยฅโกร ยคโร ยคยนร ยฅโฌ ร ยคโ ร ยคยร ยคโร ยคยพ, ร ยคโขร ยฅยร ยคยฏร ยฅโนร ยคโร ยคโขร ยคยฟร ยคยฌร ยคยฟร ยคยจร ยคยพร ยคโฐร ยคโขร ยฅยร ยคยคร ยคยตร ยคยฟร ยคโขร ยคยพร ยคยธร ยคโขร ยคยพร ยคยฐร ยฅยร ยคยฏร ยคโขร ยฅโกร ยคลร ยคยฎร ยฅโฌร ยคยจร ยคยชร ยคยฐร ยคยญร ยคยตร ยคยจร ยคยฏร ยคยพร ยคยชร ยคยฐร ยคยฟร ยคยธร ยคยฐ ร ยคโขร ยคยพ ร ยคยจร ยคยฟร ยคยฐร ยฅยร ยคยฎร ยคยพร ยคยฃร ยคยธร ยคโร ยคยญร ยคยตร ยคยนร ยฅโฌร ยคยจร ยคยนร ยฅโฌร ยคโ ร ยคยนร ยฅหร ยฅยค ร ยคโฆร ยคยคร ยคฦ ร ยคยญร ยคยตร ยคยจ/ร ยคยชร ยคยฐร ยคยฟร ยคยธร ยคยฐร ยคยจร ยคยฟร ยคยฐร ยฅยร ยคยฎร ยคยพร ยคยฃร ยคยนร ยฅโกร ยคยคร ยฅยร ยคยกร ยฅโกร ยคยตร ยคยฒร ยคยชร ยคยฎร ยฅโกร ยคโร ยคลธร ยคโขร ยคยพร ยคโขร ยคยพร ยคยฐร ยฅยร ยคยฏ ร ยคยจร ยคยฟร ยคยฐร ยฅยร ยคยฎร ยคยพร ยคยฃร ยคโขร ยคยพร ยคยฐร ยฅยร ยคยฏร ยคโขร ยฅโฌ ร ยคยถร ยฅยร ยคยฐร ยฅโกร ยคยฃร ยฅโฌ ร ยคยฎร ยฅโกร ยคโร ยคยนร ยฅโฌ ร ยคยฎร ยคยพร ยคยจร ยคยพ ร ยคลร ยคยพร ยคยร ....
X X X X Extracts X X X X
X X X X Extracts X X X X
....โฆร ยคยงร ยคยฟร ยคโขร ยคยนร ยฅโฌร ยคยนร ยฅโนร ยคโร ยคยพ, ร ยคโขร ยฅยร ยคยฏร ยฅโนร ยคโร ยคโขร ยคยฟร ยคโฐร ยคยธร ยคยฎร ยฅโกร ยคโร ยคยฌร ยฅยร ยคยจร ยคยฟร ยคยฏร ยคยพร ยคยฆร ยฅโฌ ร ยคยธร ยฅยร ยคยตร ยคยฟร ยคยงร ยคยพร ยคโร ยคโร ยคโขร ยฅโนร ยคโฐร ยคยชร ยคยฒร ยคยฌร ยฅยร ยคยงร ยคโขร ยคยฐร ยคยพร ยคยฏร ยฅโกร ยคลร ยคยพร ยคยจร ยฅโก ร ยคยนร ยฅโกร ยคยคร ยฅยร ยคโขร ยคยฟร ยคยฏร ยฅโกร ยคโร ยคยฏร ยฅโกร ยคยตร ยคยฟร ยคโขร ยคยพร ยคยธร ยคโขร ยคยพร ยคยฐร ยฅยร ยคยฏร ยฅโนร ยคโ, ร ยคลร ยฅโนร ยคยฎร ยคยพร ยคยฒร ยคยร ยคยตร ยคโร ยคยธร ยฅโกร ยคยตร ยคยพร ยคโขร ยคยฐ ร ยคโฆร ยคยงร ยคยฟร ยคยจร ยคยฟร ยคยฏร ยคยฎร ยคโขร ยฅโกร ยคโฆร ยคโร ยคยคร ยคยฐร ยฅยร ยคโร ยคยคร ยคยจร ยคยฟร ยคยฐร ยฅยร ยคยฎร ยคยพร ยคยฃ ร ยคโขร ยคยพร ยคยฐร ยฅยร ยคยฏร ยคโขร ยฅโฌ ร ยคยถร ยฅยร ยคยฐร ยฅโกร ยคยฃร ยฅโฌ ร ยคยฎร ยฅโกร ยคโ ร ยคยชร ยฅโร ยคยฐร ยฅยร ยคยต ร ยคยธร ยฅโก ร ยคยนร ยฅโฌ ร ยคยนร ยฅหร ยคโ, ร ยคโขร ยฅโกร ยคยฎร ยฅโร ยคยฒร ยฅยร ยคยฏร ยฅโนร ยคโร ยคโขร ยคยพ ร ยคโ ร ยคยจร ยฅยร ยคยชร ยคยคร ยคยฟร ยคโขร ยคยฐร ยฅโร ยคยชร ยคยธร ยฅโกร ยคยธร ยคยฎร ยคยพร ยคยตร ยฅโกร ยคยถ ร ยคยนร ยฅโนร ยคโร ยคยพร ยฅยค ร ยคโกร ยคยธ ร ยคยฎร ยฅโร ยคยฒร ยฅยร ยคยฏร ยค....