TaxTMI 
TaxTMI 
2016 (9) TMI 1538
X X X X Extracts X X X X
X X X X Extracts X X X X
....sions of the ld. DR. Identical issue with regard to the disallowance u/s 40A(3) of the Act in the case of assessee who are engaged in the business of country spirits who have paid purchases in cash had come up for consideration before this Bench in the case of Ramnagar Pachwai and C.S. (Shop) vs ITO vide ITA No.148/Kol/2015 and 185&186/Kol/2014 for A.Y.2007-08 and 2008-09 and 2010-11 respectively. This Tribunal vide its order dated on identical issue has held as follows :- "13. We have heard the rival submissions and perused the materials available on record including the paper book filed by the assessee comprising of various orders of lower authorities vide pages 1 to 42 of the Paper Book, copy of Notification No. 1208-Ex dated 29.08.2005 issued by the Excise Department, Government of West Bengal vide pages 43 to 49 of PB and copies of various decisions of High Courts and Tribunals vide pages 50 to 102 of PB. We have also gone through the provisions of The West Bengal Excise Rules 2005 and The Bengal Excise Act, 1909. The facts stated hereinabove remain undisputed and hence the same are not reiterated for the sake of brevity. At the outset, we deem it necessary to incorpo....
X X X X Extracts X X X X
X X X X Extracts X X X X
....e meanings respectively assigned to them in the Act. 3. Issue only on payment of duty.-No country spirit in labelled and capsuled bottles shall be issued without payment of duty from a country spirit bottling plant. No country spirit in bulk shall be issued without payment of duty from a country spirit warehouse. 4. Personal Ledger Account to be maintained by the wholesale licensee.-The wholesale licensee shall maintain a Personal Ledger Account in accordance with the direction issued by the Commissioner from time to time for the purpose of maintaining an account-current of the duties payable by the wholesale licensee for the issues of country spirit to the retail vendors or transport on payment of duty from the concerned country spirit bottling plant or warehouse. 5. Minimum balance in Personal Ledger Account.-The Collector shall issue directions for maintaining the minimum amount "of balance in the aforesaid Personal Ledger Accounts in order to ensure that duty for daily issues of country spirit from the country spirit bottling plant or warehouse may be debited from the said account, leaving sufficient balance as may be determined by him. 6. Pr....
X X X X Extracts X X X X
X X X X Extracts X X X X
....ler shall submit a bill in duplicate to the Officer-in-Charge of the warehouse claiming refund of the amount granted as rebate. The Officer-in-Charge shall, on receipt of the bill, refund the amount claimed after verifying his records through adjustment in the Personal Ledger Account maintained for the purpose of privilege fee. In case there is no Personal Ledger Account for privilege fee at the warehouse, the Officer-in-Charge shall send a copy of the claim with his comments to the Officer-in-Charge of the supplier bottling plant, who shall refund the amount recommended to the wholesaler through adjustment in the Personal Ledger Account maintained for privilege fee." 14. We find that the reliance placed on the decision of Co-ordinate Bench of Bangalore Tribunal in the case of Sri Renukeswara Rice Mills vs ITO reported in 93 ITD 263 (Bang Trib.) is well founded , wherein, it was held that the cash payment in the bank account of the payee is sufficient to get exemption in terms of Rule 6DD in as much it is ensured that the payee and payee alone receives the payment and the origin and conclusion of the transaction is traceable thereby fulfilling the criterion for en....
X X X X Extracts X X X X
X X X X Extracts X X X X
....gether with Rule 6DD of the Income-tax Rules, 1962, it will be clear that the provisions are not intended to restrict business activities. There is no restriction on the assessee in his trading activities. Section 40A(3) only empowers the Assessing Officer to disallow the deduction claimed as expenditure in respect of which payment is not made by crossed-cheque or crossed-bank draft. The payment by crossed- cheque or crossed bank-draft is insisted upon to enable the assessing authority to ascertain whether the payment was genuine or whether it was out of income from undisclosed sources. The terms of section 40A(3) are not absolute. Consideration of business expediency and other relevant factors are not excluded. Genuine and bona fide transactions are not taken out of the sweep of the section. It is open to the assessee to furnish to the satisfaction of the Assessing officer the circumstances under which the payment in the manner prescribed in section 40A(3) was not practicable or would have caused genuine difficulty to the payee. It is also open to the assessee to identify the person who has received the cash payment. Rule 6DD provides that an assessee can be exempted from the requ....
X X X X Extracts X X X X
X X X X Extracts X X X X
....eved the genuineness of the transaction. There was no dispute that the purchases were genuine." Anupam Tele Services vs ITO in (2014) 43 taxmann.com 199 (Guj) "Section 40A(3) of the Income-tax Act, 1961, read with rule 6DD of the Income- tax Rules, 1962 Business disallowance - Cash payment exceeding prescribed limits Rule 6DD(j) Assessment year 2006-07 - Assessee was working as an agent of Tata Tele Services Limited for distributing mobile cards and recharge vouchers - Principal company Tata insisted that cheque payment from assessee's co-operative bank would not do, since realization took longer time and such payments should be made only in cash in their bank account - If assessee would not make cash payment and make cheque payments alone, it would have received recharge vouchers delayed by 4/5 days which would severely affect its business operation - Assessee, therefore, made cash payment - Whether in view of above, no disallowance under section 40A (3) was to be made in respect of payment made to principal - Held, yes [Paras 21 to 23] [in favour of the assessee]" Sri Laxmi Sat....
X X X X Extracts X X X X
X X X X Extracts X X X X
.... of the supplier i.e M/s Asansol Bottling & Packaging Co. Pvt Ltd by the assessee. 19. We find that the Hon'ble Apex Court in the case of CTO vs Swastik Roadways reported in (2004) 3 SCC 640 had held that the consequences of non-compliance of Madhyapradesh Sales Tax Act , which were intended to check the evasion and avoidance of sales tax were significantly harsh. The court while upholding the constitutional validity negated the existence of a mens rea as a condition necessary for levy of penalty for non- compliance with such technical provisions required held that "in the consequence to follow there must be nexus between the consequence that befall for non-compliance with such provisions intended for preventing the tax evasion with the object of provision before the consequence can be inflicted upon the defaulter." The Supreme Court has opined that the existence of nexus between the tax evasion by the owner of the goods and the failure of C & F agent to furnish information required by the Commissioner is implicit in section 57(2) and the assessing authority concerned has to necessarily record a finding to this effect before levying penalty u/s 57(2). Though in th....
X X X X Extracts X X X X
X X X X Extracts X X X X
....ch payment was required to be made in legal tender. A perusal of the Government Notification issued by the Govt. of West Bengal clearly shows that the dealers are agents of the Government and the payments made are to the Government. It also makes it categorically required that the payment is to be made before lifting of the country spirit. Consequently we are of the view that the issue is squarely covered by the decision of the Coordinate Bench of this Tribunal in the case of M/s.Amrai Pachwai & C.S.Shop referred to supra wherein it has been held as follows :- "6. We have considered the rival submissions. At the outset a perusal of the assessment order clearly shows that the AO has recognized the assessee's business in trading of country spirit and country liquor. Copy of Form of Licence issued by Durgapur Municipal Corporation and copy of Form III issued by Department of Excise, Govt. of W.B. were also found at pages 177 and 179 of the assessee's paper book. In any case the validity of licence of the assessee to trade in country spirit and country liquor is not the issue before us. The issue is whether the payments made by the assessee for the purchase of country ....
X X X X Extracts X X X X
X X X X Extracts X X X X
....sesee for purchase of country spirit and country liquor is to the government as per the notification issued by the government and is in legal tender specified by the notification. In the circumstances, we are of the view that the payment made by the assessee for the purchase of country liquor and country spirit from the territorial licensee bottling plant, IFB Agro Industries Ltd., City Centre, Durgapur is protected by the exemption in terms of Rule 6DD(b) of the 1.T.Rules 1962. In the circumstances, the addition as made by the AO and as confirmed by the Id. CIT(A) by invoking the provisions of section 40A(3) of the I. T.Act 1961 stands deleted. 8. In the result the addition as confirmed by the Id. CIT(A) stands deleted. We find that this decision was rendered by placing reliance on its earlier decision in the case of M/s Amrai Pachwai & C.S.Shop in ITA No. 1251/Kol/2011 dated 15.1.2014 and after considering the contrary decisions rendered in the case of Pushpalata Mondal in ITA No. 965/Kol/2010 dated 28.7.2011 and Hon'ble Kerala High Court in the case of CIT vs K Abdu & Co (170 Taxman 297). We find that the Co-ordinate Bench decision in the case of M/s Amrai Pach....
X X X X Extracts X X X X
X X X X Extracts X X X X
....t may grant to any person, on such conditions and for such period as it may think fit, the exclusive privilege - (a) of manufacturing, or supplying by wholesale, or (b) of manufacturing, and supplying by wholesale, or (c) of selling, by wholesale or retail, or (d) of manufacturing or supplying by wholesale and selling retail, or (e) of manufacturing and supplying by wholesale and selling retail, any country liquor or intoxicating drug within any specified local area: Provided that public notice shall be given to the intention to grant any such exclusive privilege, and that any objections made by any person residing within the area affected shall be considered before an exclusive privilege is granted. (2) No grantee of any privilege under sub-section (1) shall exercise the same unless or until he has received a license in that behalf from the Collector or the Excise Commissioner. Hence it could be safely concluded that M/s Asansol Bottling & Packaging Co. Pvt Ltd (Bottling Plant) is a warehouse within the meaning of Rule 2(vii) of the Excise Rules 2005 and said warehouse is a State Government establishment, esta....