Textile finishing agent classification prevails where a post-production preparation imparts a special sewing finish.

A preparation applied after thread formation to give a special sewing finish by reducing friction was treated as a finishing agent, because its function was to impart a specific characteristic to the finished textile product rather than to operate as a lubricant in the manufacturing stream. Preparations under Heading 34.03 are used for lubrication itself, while Heading 38.09 covers products that confer a functional finish on textile material. On that reasoning, Alusil was classifiable under Heading 38.09 and not under Heading 34.03, in favour of the assessee.

---

---

Issues: Whether the product Alusil was classifiable under Heading 34.03 as a lubricating preparation or under Heading 38.09 as a finishing agent for textile use.

Analysis: The product was used in the last stage after the thread had been formed, not in the manufacture of the thread itself. Its function was to impart a special finish to the thread, making it suitable for sewing by reducing friction between the thread and the machine passage points. Preparations under Heading 34.03 are used as lubricants in the manufacturing stream or for the lubricating function itself, whereas Heading 38.09 covers preparations that impart a specific characteristic or finish to the textile product. On that basis, the product answered the description of a finishing agent and not a lubricating preparation.

Conclusion: The product was correctly classifiable under Heading 38.09 and not under Heading 34.03, in favour of the assessee.

Ratio Decidendi: Where a preparation is used on a finished textile product to impart a special functional finish, it is classifiable as a finishing agent under Heading 38.09 and not as a lubricating preparation under Heading 34.03.

---