Composite ICT school education services remain exempt where infrastructure is incidental and the dominant character is education.

ICT school programme services were treated as a single composite educational service because supply and installation of infrastructure, maintenance, teacher training, and computer education were integral to one bundled activity. The essential character of the contract was imparting education to government and government-aided schools, with infrastructure serving only as the medium of delivery. On that basis, the services fell within the negative list for the earlier period and, after the negative-list entry was omitted, continued to qualify for exemption under the corresponding mega exemption entry. The circular and exemption scheme were read consistently to preserve exemption for education-related services, so no service tax liability arose.

---

---

Issues: Whether the ICT school programme services rendered by the assessee were classifiable as naturally bundled education services falling within the negative list and later the mega exemption, and consequently not liable to service tax.

Analysis: The services under the ICT scheme were found to comprise a single bundled activity aimed at delivering computer-aided education in government and government-aided schools. The agreements, payment structure, and scheme guidelines showed that supply and installation of infrastructure, maintenance, training of teachers, and computer education to students were integral components of one composite educational service. Applying the statutory rule for bundled services, the essential character of the activity was education, while the infrastructure component was only the medium for delivery. The services answered the description of education up to higher secondary level and education as part of a curriculum leading to a qualification recognised by law, and therefore fell within the negative list for the earlier period. After the omission of the negative-list entry, the exemption was continued through the amended educational-institution entry in the mega exemption notification, so no fresh tax liability arose for the later period. The circular and exemption scheme were read consistently to preserve exemption for education-related services.

Conclusion: The services were exempt from service tax for the relevant periods, and the demand and allied objections based on vivisection and valuation could not survive.

Ratio Decidendi: Where the dominant character of a composite ICT-school contract is imparting education up to higher secondary level and the ancillary infrastructure and maintenance elements are only incidental to that educational purpose, the entire bundle is to be treated as exempt education service under the negative list or the corresponding mega exemption.

---