AI TextQuick Glance (AI)Headnote
Issues: (i) Whether the transfer pricing adjustment to brand royalty was sustainable; (ii) whether the transfer pricing adjustment to interest on external commercial borrowings was sustainable; (iii) whether depreciation was allowable on the right to use 3G spectrum; (iv) whether contractual penalties paid to the telecommunications department were deductible; (v) whether the asset restoration cost disallowance was sustainable; (vi) whether written-back capital liabilities were taxable; (vii) whether prepaid distributor discounts attracted tax deduction at source and disallowance; (viii) whether annual telecommunications licence fees were capital or revenue expenditure; (ix) whether payments for leased hardware were deductible as revenue expenditure; and (x) whether recurring spectrum usage royalty was deductible as revenue expenditure.
Issue (i): Whether the transfer pricing adjustment to brand royalty was sustainable.
Analysis: The adjustment under the comparable uncontrolled price method used a transaction between associated enterprises as a comparable. The adopted precedent applied the statutory distinction between controlled and uncontrolled transactions.
Conclusion: The royalty adjustment was set aside in favour of the assessee.
Issue (ii): Whether the transfer pricing adjustment to interest on external commercial borrowings was sustainable.
Analysis: The adopted precedent treated specific Reserve Bank of India approval as a relevant, though not conclusive, benchmark. It also identified deficiencies in the comparability analysis concerning risk, loan terms and the effective borrowing cost; the borrowing terms remained unchanged.
Conclusion: The interest adjustment was set aside in favour of the assessee.
Issue (iii): Whether depreciation was allowable on the right to use 3G spectrum.
Analysis: The spectrum acquisition expenditure was capitalised as an intangible asset. The adopted precedent distinguished spectrum rights from telecommunications service licences under section 35ABB and noted that the later spectrum amortisation provision did not apply to the assessment year.
Conclusion: Depreciation was allowable and the disallowance was set aside in favour of the assessee.
Issue (iv): Whether contractual penalties paid to the telecommunications department were deductible.
Analysis: The payments concerned non-compliance with subscriber verification and universal service agreement obligations. The adopted precedent distinguished contractual liabilities from penalties for infringement of law under section 37.
Conclusion: Both penalty disallowances were set aside in favour of the assessee.
Issue (v): Whether the asset restoration cost disallowance was sustainable.
Analysis: Lease agreements required restoration of telecom sites. The adopted precedent treated the restoration expenditure as deductible under section 37 in place of the depreciation claimed, with verification of the expenditure.
Conclusion: The restoration cost disallowance was set aside in favour of the assessee.
Issue (vi): Whether written-back capital liabilities were taxable.
Analysis: The write-back included a reversal relating to restoration costs and other capital liabilities. Their capital character and jurisdictional precedent were addressed in relation to section 28(iv).
Conclusion: The reversal of a capital liability was found not taxable under section 28(iv), but the ground was dismissed against the assessee.
Issue (vii): Whether prepaid distributor discounts attracted tax deduction at source and disallowance.
Analysis: The adopted precedent treated discounts given to prepaid distributors as distinct from commission for purposes of section 194H.
Conclusion: The disallowance for non-deduction of tax was set aside in favour of the assessee.
Issue (viii): Whether annual telecommunications licence fees were capital or revenue expenditure.
Analysis: The adopted Supreme Court precedent classified the fees as capital expenditure and provided for amortisation under section 35ABB, subject to verification of the computation.
Conclusion: The fees were capital expenditure against the assessee, with amortisation available in its favour; the disallowance was set aside.
Issue (ix): Whether payments for leased hardware were deductible as revenue expenditure.
Analysis: The hardware remained owned by the supplier. Accounting classification as a finance lease did not determine the tax treatment of payments for its use.
Conclusion: The payments were deductible as revenue expenditure, and the disallowance was set aside in favour of the assessee.
Issue (x): Whether recurring spectrum usage royalty was deductible as revenue expenditure.
Analysis: The charges were recurring payments based on revenue for spectrum and microwave frequency usage. Jurisdictional and coordinate bench precedents were applied to the identical issue.
Conclusion: The royalty expenditure was deductible as revenue expenditure, and the disallowance was set aside in favour of the assessee.
Final Conclusion: The transfer pricing adjustments and the principal expenditure disallowances were set aside. Licence fees remained capital expenditure eligible for amortisation; the capital-liability ground was dismissed despite the finding on non-taxability.
Ratio Decidendi: A controlled transaction between associated enterprises cannot serve as a comparable uncontrolled transaction under the comparable uncontrolled price method.
Brand royalty benchmarking excludes associated-enterprise transactions because controlled dealings cannot qualify as uncontrolled comparables for transfer pricing.
Associated-enterprise transactions cannot serve as uncontrolled comparables when benchmarking brand royalty under the comparable uncontrolled price method. Interest benchmarking for external commercial borrowings considers risk, loan terms and effective borrowing costs; specific RBI approval is relevant but not conclusive. Capitalised rights to use 3G spectrum qualify for depreciation where the later spectrum amortisation provision does not apply. Contractual penalties for subscriber verification and universal service non-compliance are deductible when distinct from penalties for infringement of law. Telecom site restoration costs are deductible instead of claimed depreciation, subject to verification. Prepaid distributor discounts are not commission for tax deduction purposes. Annual telecommunications licence fees are capital expenditure eligible for amortisation under section 35ABB. Payments for supplier-owned leased hardware and recurring spectrum usage charges are revenue expenditure; finance lease accounting does not determine the hardware payments' tax treatment.
Transfer pricing Adjustment - Brand royalty and controlled comparables under CUP - Transfer pricing - Arm's length interest on external commercial borrowings - Depreciation on the right to use 3G spectrum - Deductibility of DoT payments for contractual defaults - Deduction for telecom-site restoration obligations - Taxability of capital liabilities written back - Withholding tax on discounts to prepaid distributors - Amortisation of revenue-share telecom licence fees - Deductibility of IBM hardware lease charges - Revenue expenditure on recurring spectrum-usage royalty TP Adjustment - Brand royalty and controlled comparables under CUP - Sustainability of the brand-royalty adjustment based on a royalty agreement between associated enterprises as a comparable under the CUP method - HELD THAT: - CUP benchmarking requires a comparable uncontrolled transaction; an agreement between associated enterprises does not satisfy that requirement. Following its earlier decision on identical facts [2026 (3) TMI 1481 - ITAT DELHI], the Tribunal held that the adjustment founded on related-party royalty agreements could not be sustained. [Paras 10, 11] The transfer pricing adjustment relating to payment of brand royalty was deleted. Transfer pricing - Arm's length interest on external commercial borrowings - RBI-approved borrowing cost and comparability adjustments - HELD THAT: - The Tribunal followed its earlier decision [2026 (7) TMI 345 - ITAT MUMBAI] concerning the same ECB arrangements. That decision treated RBI approval as a relevant, though not conclusive, benchmark and accepted the approved effective all-in-cost as more reliable where the TPO's analysis omitted material adjustments for country risk, currency risk, tenure, borrower profile and subordination. Upfront fees formed part of the borrowing cost, and unchanged borrowing terms supported adherence to the earlier view. [Paras 14, 15] The transfer pricing adjustment to interest on the ECB facilities was deleted. Depreciation on the right to use 3G spectrum - Allowance of depreciation under section 32 on acquired 3G spectrum rights instead of amortisation as telecom licence expenditure under section 35ABB - HELD THAT: - The Tribunal followed its earlier decision [2026 (3) TMI 1481 - ITAT DELHI] on identical facts deleting the disallowance of depreciation on 3G spectrum rights claimed as an intangible asset. On that basis, the substitution of amortisation under section 35ABB for the depreciation claimed under section 32 was not sustained. [Paras 18] The disallowance of depreciation on the right to use 3G spectrum was deleted. Deductibility of DoT payments for contractual defaults - Deductibility of payments to DoT for subscriber-verification defaults and non-compliance with Universal Service Obligation agreement terms - HELD THAT: - Both disallowances were treated as covered by the earlier decision [2026 (3) TMI 1481 - ITAT DELHI] allowing deduction of DoT payments arising from non-compliance with contractual terms. Following that decision, the Tribunal did not sustain their disallowance by invoking the Explanation to section 37(1). [Paras 22] The disallowances relating to subscriber-verification and Universal Service Obligation defaults were deleted. Deduction for telecom-site restoration obligations - Allowance of asset restoration expenditure for leased telecom sites u/s 37(1), in place of depreciation on capitalised restoration costs - HELD THAT: - The earlier decision followed by the Tribunal [2026 (3) TMI 1481 - ITAT DELHI] had applied the jurisdictional High Court's ruling of Vodafone Mobile Services Ltd. vs. DCIT [2025 (3) TMI 659 - DELHI HIGH COURT] to allow asset restoration expenditure under section 37(1), rather than depreciation on the capitalised obligation. That decision required withdrawal of the depreciation claim and verification of the expenditure for allowance as revenue expenditure. [Paras 25] The disallowance was set aside and the ground allowed on the basis of the earlier decision permitting deduction under section 37(1), in place of depreciation, subject to verification. Taxability of capital liabilities written back - Taxability of liabilities written back, comprising reversal of asset restoration provisions and unclaimed customer security deposits - HELD THAT: - Referring to the authorities concerning waiver of capital liabilities, the Tribunal recorded that reversal of a capital liability could not be brought to tax under section 28(iv). Its operative conclusion on this ground, however, did not accord with that stated reasoning. [Paras 29] The ground challenging the addition for liabilities written back was nevertheless expressly dismissed. Withholding tax on discounts to prepaid distributors - Disallowance for non-deduction of tax on distributor discounts - Disallowance under section 40(a)(ia) for non-deduction of tax u/s 194H on discounts allowed to prepaid SIM-card distributors - HELD THAT: - The Supreme Court Bharti Cellular Ltd. [2024 (3) TMI 41 - SUPREME COURT] had held that discounts given to prepaid distributors were not commission attracting section 194H. Following that ruling and its earlier decision in the assessee's own case, the Tribunal held that the consequential disallowance under section 40(a)(ia) could not survive. [Paras 32] The disallowance of discounts allowed to prepaid distributors was deleted. Amortisation of revenue-share telecom licence fees - Treatment of annual revenue-share telecom licence fees as revenue expenditure under section 37(1) or capital expenditure amortisable under section 35ABB - HELD THAT: - The Supreme Court ruling Bharti Hexacom Ltd. [2023 (10) TMI 786 - SUPREME COURT] followed by the Tribunal treated the licence fees as capital expenditure eligible for amortisation under section 35ABB, rather than an outright revenue deduction. The earlier decision in the assessee's own case accordingly required verification of the computation and allowance of the amortised amount attributable to the year. [Paras 35] The disallowance was set aside and the ground allowed by following the earlier direction to verify the computation and allow amortisation under section 35ABB. Deductibility of IBM hardware lease charges - Accounting treatment and tax deductibility of lease rentals - Deductibility of charges paid for use of IBM-owned hardware despite their capitalisation as finance leases in the books - HELD THAT: - Accounting classification under AS-19 does not determine treatment under the Income-tax Act. The reasoning adopted by the Tribunal distinguished ownership from use: IBM retained ownership of the hardware, while the assessee paid for its business use. Lease charges incurred without acquiring ownership rights were allowable as revenue expenditure under section 37(1), notwithstanding their capitalisation in the accounts. [Paras 38] The disallowance of payments made to IBM was deleted. Revenue expenditure on recurring spectrum-usage royalty - Deductibility of recurring WPC royalty for use of spectrum and microwave frequencies instead of capitalisation with depreciation - HELD THAT: - The Tribunal treated the issue as covered by the jurisdictional High Court's decision Vodafone West Limited' (earlier known as Fascel Limited') [2008 (12) TMI 743 - DELHI HIGH COURT] and its own earlier decision [2026 (3) TMI 1481 - ITAT DELHI] allowing recurring WPC spectrum-usage charges as revenue expenditure. Following those authorities, it did not sustain capitalisation of the payments and restriction of the deduction to depreciation. [Paras 41] The disallowance arising from capitalisation of WPC royalty expenses was deleted. Final Conclusion: The appeal was recorded as allowed, notwithstanding the express dismissal of the ground concerning liabilities written back. The consequential grounds were left open.