AI TextQuick Glance (AI)Headnote
Rural agricultural land exclusion depends on aerial distance, while claimed co-ownership requires evidence to apportion capital gains.
Agricultural land within eight kilometres aerially of a municipality with a population exceeding ten lakh is a capital asset for the relevant assessment year; road distance does not establish the applicable statutory distance. The land was within that aerial limit, and revenue records showed it was fallow or vacant, with insufficient evidence of agricultural operations, making the rural agricultural land exclusion unavailable. Family members' inclusion in a sale deed alone did not establish beneficial ownership or shares. The assessee funded acquisition of the main parcel, records for the other parcel named the assessee alone, and the claimed co-owners' ownership was not established. The entire capital gain was therefore assessable to the assessee.
Nature of land sold - Agricultural land v/s capital asset - Aerial distance from municipal limits - Capital gains apportionment - Proof of beneficial co-ownership Nature of land sold - Agricultural land v/s capital asset - Aerial distance from municipal limits - Status of agricultural land as a capital asset where its certified aerial distance fell within the statutory limit although its road distance exceeded that limit - HELD THAT: - Section 2(14)(iii)(b), as amended by the Finance Act, 2013, requires distance from municipal limits to be measured aerially. Where the municipal population exceeds ten lakh, agricultural land within eight kilometres falls within the definition of a capital asset. The Survey of India certified an aerial distance of 5.9 kilometres, bringing the land within the prescribed limit. The PWD certificate recording road distance did not establish the distance required by the provision. Further, the revenue records indicated that the land was fallow or vacant, and sufficient evidence of actual agricultural operations had not been furnished. [Paras 13, 14, 16, 17, 18] The land constituted a capital asset under section 2(14)(iii)(b), and the claim that the gains were not chargeable to tax as arising from rural agricultural land was rejected. Capital gains apportionment - Proof of beneficial co-ownership - Assessment of the entire capital gains in the assessee's hands where the claimed co-ownership and allocation among family members were not substantiated - HELD THAT: - Mere inclusion of family members in a sale deed does not conclusively establish their beneficial ownership or the proportion in which capital gains are assessable. Apportionment requires documentary evidence establishing the nature and extent of their ownership rights. Although the principal purchase deed named the assessee and his son, the assessee admitted funding the entire purchase, and no contribution by the son was established. Adequate evidence of the wife's legal or beneficial ownership was also absent. The revenue record for the other parcel named the assessee alone. The respective beneficial interests and claimed allocation of consideration remained unsubstantiated. [Paras 20, 21, 22, 23, 24] Assessment of the entire long-term capital gains in the assessee's hands was upheld. Final Conclusion: The assessee's appeal was dismissed, and the order sustaining the assessment of the entire long-term capital gains in his hands was upheld.