AI TextQuick Glance (AI)Headnote
Gold confiscation: local sourcing evidence can shift the burden, while cash confiscation requires a link to smuggled goods.
The possessor bears the burden of proving that gold or its manufactures are not smuggled when seizure is based on reasonable belief under the Customs Act. Credible invoices, stock records and supplier statements supporting lawful local acquisition may shift the evidential burden to customs authorities. Incomplete identification of bullion and inadequate investigation can undermine an allegation of smuggled origin. Confiscation of currency as sale proceeds requires evidence linking it to smuggled goods; concealment of cash alone does not establish that link.
Burden of proof in inland seizure of gold bullion and jewellery - Confiscation of currency as alleged proceeds of smuggled gold Burden of proof in inland seizure of gold bullion and jewellery - Proof of smuggled character of gold bullion and jewellery seized in inland transit where invoices, accounts and suppliers' statements established local procurement - HELD THAT: - The presumption concerning jewellery intercepted at international transit points is not available merely because jewellery is found in inland transit. Documentary evidence, accounts and suppliers' statements establishing local procurement shift the evidential onus to the department. The appellant sufficiently established accounted local purchases, while most bullion bore Indian manufacturers' marks. The cut piece bearing the SAM marking lacked a bullion number and separately established purity, and the valuer had not differentiated the bullion pieces. Failure to carry all purchase invoices and books during transit did not justify rejecting the subsequently produced records. The department neither adequately investigated the purchase evidence and suppliers' bona fides nor established a smuggling trail. No evidence linked the unmarked jewellery to smuggled bullion, and comparable stock at the business premises had been accepted as indigenous. [Paras 3, 4, 5] The confiscation of the gold bullion and jewellery was unsustainable, the department's case failing even on a preponderance of probability. Confiscation of currency as alleged proceeds of smuggled gold - Confiscation of Indian currency recovered during inland transit without evidence connecting it to smuggled gold or jewellery manufactured from such gold - HELD THAT: - Currency does not become connected with smuggled goods merely because it is not kept openly. The manner in which a traveller keeps cash is a matter of personal choice, not proof of a smuggling nexus. Neither evidence nor any inculpatory admission linked the recovered currency to smuggled gold. [Paras 3, 4] The confiscation of the Indian currency could not be sustained. Final Conclusion: The appeal was allowed with consequential relief.