Classification consistency for mixed spice products led to interim protection and a stay on coercive action.

A prior accepted classification of the same mixed spice products under heading 09109100 weighed against the later impugned classification order, which departed from that position without apparent judicial discipline. The court found prima facie force in the contention that the fresh classification was inconsistent with the earlier accepted view for the petitioner's own product category. Pending a reply affidavit and further consideration, interim protection was granted and coercive action under the impugned order was stayed until the next hearing date.

---

---

Issues: Whether the impugned classification order could be permitted to operate when an earlier order in the petitioner's own case had accepted classification of the same type of spice mixes under heading 09109100, and whether interim protection against coercive action was warranted.

Analysis: The earlier adjudication in the petitioner's own matter had accepted the classification of mixed spice products under heading 09109100 and had attained acceptance in departmental proceedings. The later order departed from that position without following the principle of judicial discipline, despite the same broad product category and the need for consistency in classification. The Court found prima facie substance in the contention that the later approach appeared perverse and inconsistent with the earlier accepted view. Pending further consideration and a reply affidavit from the respondent, the Court granted interim protection against coercive steps under the impugned order.

Conclusion: The petitioner was granted interim relief and coercive action under the impugned order was stayed until the next date of hearing.

---