Set-off of joint venture loss against company income fails where the loss belongs to a separate assessable entity.

A company could not set off its share of loss from a joint venture against its own other income because the venture was treated as a separate assessable entity. On the facts, the joint venture was regarded either as an unregistered firm or, in any event, an association of persons, so the loss did not belong to the same assessee as the company. The right of set-off under the Income-tax Act applies only where the loss and income are assessed in the same hands, or where the statute specifically permits adjustment, such as in the case of a firm. The assessee-company was therefore not entitled to the set-off.

---

---

Issues: Whether the assessee-company could set off its share of loss from a joint venture carried on with other companies against its other income.

Analysis: The joint venture was treated as a distinct income-tax entity, separate from the assessee-company. On the facts found, the venture was either an unregistered firm or, in any event, a different assessable entity such as an association of persons. The right of set-off under the Income-tax Act applies where the same assessee is being assessed, or within the statutory framework applicable to a firm; it does not permit a company to adjust a loss belonging to a separate assessable entity against its own income. The distinction drawn in earlier authorities concerning set-off within the same assessee or under business income computations did not assist the assessee on these facts.

Conclusion: The assessee-company was not entitled to set off the joint venture loss against its other income, and the answer to the referred question was in the negative.

Ratio Decidendi: Set-off of business loss against other income is permissible only where the loss and the income belong to the same assessee, or where the statute specifically allows such adjustment; a loss belonging to a separate assessable entity cannot be carried into the individual assessment of a company partner.

---