Contemporaneous import testing prevails where crude palm oil degrades over time, preserving concessional notification eligibility.

Contemporaneous import-stage laboratory results prevailed over delayed retesting for crude palm oil where the commodity was shown to deteriorate with time and temperature. The Tribunal accepted the favourable Customs Laboratory test conducted on import, found no defect in that method, and held that a later CRCL report based on an aged sample from one vessel sample could not reliably represent a nine-tank consignment. On that basis, the crude palm oil satisfied the notification conditions for concessional assessment, and the demand founded on the adverse delayed report was not sustainable.

---

---

Issues: Whether the crude palm oil imported by the appellants satisfied the conditions of Notification No. 21/02-Cus. dated 01.03.2002 and was entitled to concessional assessment, despite the later CRCL test results showing lower carotene content.

Analysis: The goods were tested immediately on import by the Customs Laboratory, Cochin, and those results were favourable. A single sample drawn by DRI from the vessel was sent much later for testing at CFTRI and then CRCL, while the consignment consisted of nine separate tanks. The Tribunal accepted the technical material showing that beta carotene in crude palm oil diminishes with lapse of time and temperature variations. It also noted that there was no material to show any defect in the Cochin laboratory method, and that delayed testing could not reliably displace the contemporaneous import-stage test, particularly where the samples had materially aged before CRCL analysis.

Conclusion: The crude palm oil was held to satisfy the notification conditions, and the demand based on the adverse CRCL report was not sustainable.

Ratio Decidendi: For a consignment-dependent exemption or concessional notification, contemporaneous laboratory results at the time of import prevail over delayed testing where the commodity is scientifically shown to undergo deterioration with time and the later sample is not shown to be representative of the entire consignment.

---