Cash refund of unutilised Modvat credit turns on duty-paid inputs and their use in manufacture before the levy change.

Cash refund of unutilised Modvat credit could be claimed under the refund provision where duty-paid inputs had been used in or in relation to manufacture before the assessee shifted to the compounded levy scheme, and the mere inability to utilise the credit did not by itself defeat entitlement. The matter required fresh examination because the lower authorities had not verified the duty-paid character of the inputs or their use in manufacture, so the refund claim had to be reconsidered on those factual aspects.

---

---

Issues: Whether the assessee was entitled to cash refund of unutilised Modvat credit on inputs under the refund provision when the final products were cleared under the compounded levy scheme, and whether the matter required fresh examination by the original authority.

Analysis: The refund claim was made for the duty equivalent to outstanding unutilised credit that could not be utilised after the assessee shifted to the compounded levy scheme. The governing refund provision expressly contemplated cash refund of duty credit on excisable inputs used in accordance with the rules or notifications under the Act. The authority held that the assessee's inability to use the credit did not defeat the statutory entitlement where the inputs were duty-paid and had been used in or in relation to manufacture before the relevant date. The record had not been examined on those factual aspects by the lower authorities.

Conclusion: The assessee was entitled to have the refund claim considered under the refund provision, and the matter was required to be sent back for verification of the duty-paid nature of the inputs and their use in manufacture.

---