Place of importation for customs valuation includes the approved unloading point, and barge charges were part of transport cost.

Imported goods are treated as reaching the place of importation only when landed at the approved unloading point, not at the anchorage where the mother vessel waits. Movement by barge from the vessel to the approved jetty was therefore part of the process of landing the goods in India, and the associated expenditure formed part of transport cost for valuation. On that basis, barge charges incurred to move the iron ore to Dharamtar were includible in the assessable value, and the assessment orders were sustained.

---

---

Issues: (i) Whether the place of importation was the Bombay Floating Light or Dharamtar Port; (ii) Whether the barge charges incurred for moving the iron ore from the mother vessel to Dharamtar were includible in the assessable value as transportation costs.

Issue (i): Whether the place of importation was the Bombay Floating Light or Dharamtar Port.

Analysis: The place approved for unloading under the Customs framework was Dharamtar Port, while the Bombay Floating Light was only the anchorage point. Imported goods could be unloaded only at the approved place, and transportation by barges from the mother vessel to the jetty was merely a step in the process of landing the goods on the landmass of India. The statutory scheme governing unloading, water-borne movement, and clearance for home consumption supported the view that import was not complete at the anchorage point.

Conclusion: The place of importation was Dharamtar Port, not the Bombay Floating Light.

Issue (ii): Whether the barge charges incurred for moving the iron ore from the mother vessel to Dharamtar were includible in the assessable value as transportation costs.

Analysis: Under the valuation rule, the assessable value includes the cost of transport of imported goods to the place of importation, along with associated loading, unloading, and handling charges. Since the goods were not imported at the anchorage point but at Dharamtar, the extra expenditure incurred for carriage by barges formed part of the cost of transportation to the place of importation. The fact that the charges were incurred by the importer did not exclude them from the valuation formula.

Conclusion: The barge charges were includible in the assessable value as transportation cost.

Final Conclusion: The assessment orders were sustained because the unloading point was not the place of importation and the barging expenses were part of the transportation cost for valuation purposes.

Ratio Decidendi: For customs valuation, imported goods are taken to reach the place of importation only when they are landed at the approved unloading point, and any expenditure incurred to move them from the mother vessel to that point is includible as transport cost under the valuation rule.

---