Adventure in the nature of trade characterised by totality of circumstances; excess sale proceeds treated as revenue receipt and taxable.

Whether the excess proceeds on sale of 13,74,000 shares constituted revenue or capital receipt was analysed as a mixed question of law and fact; the Court applied the totality-of-circumstances test, examining promoters' and company's intention, contemporaneous brokerage-sale arrangements, separate valuation for managing agency, necessity to part-sell to finance acquisition, and the company's limited capital. Applying those legal indicia, the transactions were characterised as a commercial venture undertaken for quick resale and profit, and the excess sum was treated as a revenue receipt liable to tax.

---

---

Issues: Whether the excess sum of Rs. 16,52,600 realised on sale of 13,74,000 shares was a revenue receipt being profit from an adventure in the nature of trade, or a capital receipt (not taxable) under section 4(3)(vii) of the Income-tax Act.

Analysis: The Court examined the facts found by the Investigation Commission concerning the promoters' and company's intention, the contemporaneous arrangements with brokers to sell the bulk of the shares, the separate valuation and payment for the managing agency, the necessity of selling part of the block to finance the acquisition, and the company's limited capital. These facts were treated as a mixed question of law and fact where the legal effect of the findings determines whether the transaction was an adventure in the nature of trade. Applying the established test of the totality of circumstances, the Court found that the purchase-and-sale transactions displayed all attributes of a commercial venture undertaken for quick resale and profit, distinct from an investment retained as capital.

Conclusion: The sale of the 13,74,000 shares was an adventure in the nature of trade and the amount of Rs. 16,52,600 is a revenue receipt and therefore taxable (decision in favour of Revenue).

---