Transfer pricing relief granted with 15% reliability premium on grid rate, section 80-IA deductions upheld

ITAT Jaipur partly allowed the assessee's appeal regarding transfer pricing of power for section 80-IA deduction. The tribunal granted 15% reliability charge premium on grid rate instead of claimed amount, following precedent allowing premium for uninterrupted power supply. Education cess was disallowed due to retrospective amendment by Finance Act 2022. Depreciation on leasehold rights was allowed at 25% as business/commercial rights. Interest on delayed TDS deposit was permitted as business expenditure. Various section 80-IA deductions for captive power, solid waste, water treatment, and rail systems were upheld based on consistency principle, as department had accepted similar methods in previous years. Sales tax subsidy was treated as capital receipt, not taxable under regular provisions or MAT.

---

---

1. ISSUES PRESENTED and CONSIDERED

The core legal questions considered in this judgment include:

• Whether the assessee is entitled to claim a reliability charge in computing the transfer price of power for deduction under section 80-IA.
• Whether the education cess is an allowable deduction under section 40(a)(ii).
• Whether the profit on the sale of investments and fixed assets should be excluded while computing book profit under section 115JB.
• Whether the deduction under sections 80IA and 80IC should be allowed while computing book profit under section 115JB.
• Whether the claim of depreciation on leasehold rights should be allowed under section 32(1)(ii).
• Whether interest on late deposit of TDS is an allowable business expenditure under section 37(1).
• Whether the disallowance of deductions under section 80IA for captive power plants, solid waste management, water treatment systems, and rail systems was justified.
• Whether the subsidies received under the Rajasthan Investment Promotion Scheme should be treated as capital receipts and excluded from taxable income.

2. ISSUE-WISE DETAILED ANALYSIS

Reliability Charge in Transfer Price of Power:

• The Court considered the reliability charge for providing uninterrupted power supply as part of the transfer price for deduction under section 80-IA. The Court found that the reliability charge is justified, referencing industry practices and similar cases, allowing a charge of Rs. 1.10 per unit.

Education Cess Deduction:

• The Court addressed whether the education cess is deductible under section 40(a)(ii). The retrospective amendment by the Finance Act, 2022, clarified that education cess is not an allowable deduction, affirming the disallowance by the AO.

Profit on Sale of Investments and Fixed Assets:

• The Court upheld the disallowance of excluding profit from the sale of investments and fixed assets in computing book profit under section 115JB, following precedent in the assessee's own case.

Deduction under Sections 80IA and 80IC in Book Profit:

• The Court discussed whether deductions under sections 80IA and 80IC should be considered while computing book profit under section 115JB. The Court concluded against the assessee, referencing previous Tribunal decisions.

Depreciation on Leasehold Rights:

• The Court admitted the claim for depreciation on leasehold rights as a legal issue, allowing it under section 32(1)(ii) based on judicial precedents that treat such rights as intangible assets.

Interest on Late Deposit of TDS:

• The Court allowed the deduction of interest on late deposit of TDS as a business expenditure, considering it compensatory rather than penal.

Deductions under Section 80IA for Various Infrastructure Facilities:

• The Court examined the disallowance of deductions for captive power plants, solid waste management, water treatment systems, and rail systems. The Court upheld the CIT (A)'s partial allowance based on consistent application of methodologies accepted in previous and subsequent years.

Subsidies under Rajasthan Investment Promotion Scheme:

• The Court treated subsidies received under the Rajasthan Investment Promotion Scheme as capital receipts, following the jurisdictional High Court's decisions, and excluded them from taxable income under both regular provisions and section 115JB.

3. SIGNIFICANT HOLDINGS

Reliability Charge: The Court allowed a reliability charge of Rs. 1.10 per unit for uninterrupted power supply, supporting the industry practice and similar rulings.

Education Cess: The Court upheld the disallowance of education cess as a deduction, aligning with the retrospective amendment in the Finance Act, 2022.

Profit on Sale of Investments and Fixed Assets: The Court maintained the disallowance of excluding such profits in computing book profit under section 115JB, consistent with prior rulings.

Deduction under Sections 80IA and 80IC in Book Profit: The Court denied the inclusion of these deductions in computing book profit under section 115JB, following established precedents.

Depreciation on Leasehold Rights: The Court allowed depreciation on leasehold rights under section 32(1)(ii), treating them as intangible assets.

Interest on Late Deposit of TDS: The Court permitted the deduction of interest on late TDS deposit as a business expense, considering it compensatory.

Deductions under Section 80IA for Infrastructure Facilities: The Court upheld partial allowances for deductions, adhering to consistent methodologies accepted in previous and subsequent assessments.

Subsidies under Rajasthan Investment Promotion Scheme: The Court affirmed the treatment of subsidies as capital receipts, excluding them from taxable income, in line with jurisdictional High Court rulings.

---