Marketability test for excise duty: captive calcium carbide without saleable condition was held not excisable.

Excise duty applies only to manufactured goods that satisfy the test of marketability in their existing form. The Court accepted Moti Laminates as stating the correct law and held that a commodity used captively, but lacking the purity and packaging needed for sale in the market as produced, is not excisable merely because it could be made marketable by further processing. On the facts found, the calcium carbide was not marketable in its existing condition and therefore did not attract excise duty.

---

---

Issues: Whether calcium carbide manufactured for captive use in the factory, and not marketable in its existing condition, was liable to excise duty as excisable goods under the tariff entry.

Analysis: Excise duty is attracted on goods that are manufactured or produced and, for that purpose, the goods must satisfy the test of marketability. The earlier decision in Moti Laminates was accepted as laying down the correct law. On the facts found by the Collector, the calcium carbide produced by the respondent lacked the purity and packaging that would make it marketable in the market as it was. The commodity sought to be taxed must be marketable in its existing form and not merely capable of being made marketable by further processing.

Conclusion: The calcium carbide manufactured by the respondent was not excisable and the appeal failed.

Ratio Decidendi: Goods are liable to excise only if they are manufactured goods that are marketable in the form in which they exist, and a product used captively without marketability does not attract excise duty.

---