Tribunal Reduces Tax Addition: Rs. 7.76L Cash Addition Deleted, Rs. 72.23L Stock Addition Cut to Rs. 45.32L

The Tribunal partly allowed the assessee's appeal. It deleted the addition of Rs. 7,76,500/- related to excess cash, as the cash was accounted for as sales on the survey date, preventing double taxation. Regarding the Rs. 72,23,450/- addition for excess stock, the Tribunal accepted a benchmark GP rate for recalculating the closing stock, allowing a credit of Rs. 26,90,788/-. Consequently, the addition was reduced to Rs. 45,32,662/-.

---

---

Issues Involved:
1. Opportunity of being heard.
2. Addition of Rs. 7,76,500/- on account of excess cash.
3. Addition of Rs. 72,23,450/- on account of excess stock.

Summary:

Issue 1: Opportunity of Being Heard
The assessee claimed that the CIT(A) passed the appeal order without affording a reasonable opportunity of being heard. However, this ground was dismissed as not pressed.

Issue 2: Addition of Rs. 7,76,500/- on Account of Excess Cash
The assessee argued that the excess cash found during the survey was accounted for as sales and treated as revenue receipt, thus no justification for the addition. The CIT(A) confirmed the addition, noting that the excess cash was not declared in the return of income. The Tribunal found that the assessee had shown the excess cash as sales on the date of the survey, thus it was part of the sales declared for the relevant period. Therefore, no further addition was required, and any further addition would result in double taxation. Accordingly, this ground of the assessee was allowed.

Issue 3: Addition of Rs. 72,23,450/- on Account of Excess Stock
The assessee contended that the addition was made on an illegal and arbitrary basis, resulting in double addition. The CIT(A) upheld the addition, noting that the appellant could not explain the excess stock found during the survey. The Tribunal observed that the entire stock inventoried by the survey team could not be treated as unaccounted stock. The Tribunal accepted the GP rate of 3.45% as a benchmark for reverse calculation to ascertain the closing stock. Consequently, the Tribunal allowed credit for Rs. 26,90,788/- as closing stock out of the alleged unaccounted stock of Rs. 72,23,450/-. The addition was restricted to Rs. 45,32,662/-. Accordingly, this ground was partly allowed.

Conclusion:
The appeal of the assessee was partly allowed, with the addition of Rs. 7,76,500/- being deleted and the addition of Rs. 72,23,450/- being restricted to Rs. 45,32,662/-.

---