AI TextQuick Glance (AI)Headnote
Assistant Commissioner's order under Section 143 allows Rs. 23,31,308 cenvat credit after deducting inadmissible amounts
Calcutta HC disposed of a writ petition concerning implementation of an Assistant Commissioner's order under Section 143 of WBGST/CGST Act, 2017 regarding inadmissible ITC. The petitioner's cenvat credit claim was allowed for Rs. 25,30,178 as ITC after deducting Rs. 14,454.65 from the original claim of Rs. 25,44,632.62. Since transitional cenvat credit of Rs. 1,98,870 for November 2017 was already credited in December 2017, the final allowable amount was Rs. 23,31,308. The court found authorities may have erroneously subtracted Rs. 1,98,870 from the allowable credit during implementation. HC directed respondents to credit Rs. 23,31,308 as cenvat credit ITC and Rs. 19,019.7 as SGST credit to petitioner's ledger if not already credited, after verifying the ledger.
Failure on the part of the concerned respondents to implement the order passed by the Assistant Commissioner u/s 143 of the WBGST/CGST Act, 2017 - inadmissible ITC - HELD THAT:- It is amply clear that the claim of cenvat credit of the petitioner was allowed to the extent of Rs. 25,30,178/- as ITC by deducting the disallowed amount of Rs. 14,454.65/- from the original claim of Rs. 25,44,632.62/-. Since, records reveals that transitional cenvat credit amount of Rs. 1,98,870/- for the period of November, 2017 had been credited on 26th December, 2017 in the CGST ledger during the filing of earlier Tran-1 on 26th December, 2017, the claim on account of cenvat credit was allowed to the extent of Rs. 23,31,308/- as ITC by subtracting 1,98,870 from 25,30,178/-. It appears that while implementing the said order the authorities may have erroneously subtracted the sum of Rs. 1,98,870/- from the allowable cenvat credit as ITC of 23,31,308/-. Though, the entire records are not available and though Mr. Dey could not enlighten this Court as to whether the amount of Rs. 23,31,308/- had in fact being credited to the petitioner on account of cenvat credit as ITC, if such amount has not already been credited to forthwith credit the same to the petitioner’s ledger - Insofar as SGST credit is concerned to the extent of Rs. 19,019.7/-, the same should also be credited to the petitioner’s ledger having regard to the directions contained in the order dated 24th February, 2023, if the same has already not been credited. However, the respondents are directed to verify the petitioner’s ledger before effecting such credit. The writ petition is disposed of.