AI TextQuick Glance (AI)Headnote
Sale of Sweet Boxes Not Service Taxable; RCM Demand and Penalties Quashed Under Section 65B(44)(b)
The CESTAT Kolkata held that the sale of sweet boxes constituted a pure sale of goods, not liable to service tax under outdoor catering services, and set aside the demand of Rs. 56,159. Service tax demand under RCM for manpower supply services was also set aside, as the service provider had already paid the tax, avoiding double taxation. Service tax confirmed on directors' remuneration was quashed, as salary paid to directors as employees falls outside the definition of service under Section 65B(44)(b). The disallowance of CENVAT credit on maintenance services was reversed, recognizing the appellant's entitlement under CENVAT Credit Rules. Penalties imposed were also set aside due to the unsustainable tax demands. The appeal was allowed in full, with all demands and penalties quashed.
Levy of service tax - sale of sweet boxes - Levy of service tax under the category of Manpower supply services received from various providers - Service tax confirmed on the remuneration paid to Four directors - Disallowance of CENVAT Credit availed by the appellant on the invoice - Reversal of Cenvat credit - disallowance on the ground that service tax was not paid by M/s Sonu Services under RCM - levy of penalties. Levy of service tax - sale of sweet boxes - HELD THAT:- It is found that the supply of sweet boxes is a transaction of sale of goods and no element of service involved in the said transaction. The dominant nature of the transaction was sale only, and no services, amenities etc. were offered to the customers along with the sale of sweet boxes. The mere fact that the Appellant is registered as an outdoor catering service provider cannot be the reason to conclude that all transactions undertaken by them would be taxable under outdoor catering service. It is found that when the sweet boxes were delivered as per customer order, It is a sale of goods and the said transaction cannot be treated as outdoor catering service simply because the seller is registered under that category. The copy of the sample invoices submitted by the appellant is perused. The invoices clearly indicate that the transaction was a sale. Accordingly, no service tax is liable to be paid on a transaction which is a pure ‘sale’ - the demand of service tax Rs.56,159/- confirmed on the sale of sweet boxes is not sustainable. Levy of service tax under the category of Manpower supply services received from various providers - HELD THAT:- The service tax has been collected and paid by the service provider M/s. Sonu Services, even though legally service receiver is liable to pay service tax on RCM basis. On such services. However, it is observed that demanding service tax again from the recipient under RCM would amount to double taxation. This view has been held by Tribunal Bangalore in the case of Kerala Ceramics Ltd. v. CCE [2024 (5) TMI 868 - CESTAT BANGALORE] - the service tax cannot be demanded again from the appellant under RCM, as the service tax in this case has already been paid by the service provider M/s. Sonu Services. Thus, the demand of service tax confirmed in the impugned order on this count is not sustainable and the same is set aside. Service tax confirmed on the remuneration paid to Four directors - remuneration has been paid to the directors as salary and on such amount TDS was also deducted under the salary head under section 192 of the Income Tax Act, 1961& Form 16 was being issued to such directors - HELD THAT:- It is observed that the service provided by Director as an employee to the employer is not liable to pay service tax as per Section 65B (44) of the Finance Act, 1994. As per the sub clause (b) of sub-Section (44) of Section 65 of Finance Act, 1994, it is clear that provision of any service by an employee to the employer during the course of his employment does not fall under the definition of service. In the present case, it is found that the Directors to whom the salary was paid by the appellant are employees of the Company. Thus, the Directors, in the capacity of employees provided service to the employer i.e. present appellant Company. Therefore, the service provided by the Directors to the appellant Company, is in the course of their employment is out of the purview of service in terms of Section 65B(44) (b) of the Finance Act, 1994 - CBEC has also clarified the issue vide Circular No. 115/9/2009-ST dated 31.07.2009, wherein it has been clarified that any salary paid to the Directors of the Company is outside the scope of service - thus, any salary paid to the Directors of the Company for the service rendered by him as an employee of the company, is outside the scope of service - no service tax would be leviable on such amount - the demand of service tax on this count is not sustainable and is set aside. Disallowance of CENVAT Credit of Rs.21,250/- availed by the appellant on the invoices raised by M/s Anandlok Welfare Association - HELD THAT:- The said Association has raised the invoices for maintenance services provided in respect of the flat owned by the Appellant at 227, AJC Bose Road, Kolkata-700020. The said property is given on rent to M/s Corporation Bank for which the Appellant pays service tax as a provider of renting of immovable property service. It is found that the department has not disputed payment of Service tax on the said property even though the address is different than that of the Appellant’s registration. However, at the time of availment of credit, the department has denied the credit on the ground that the address wherefrom the services were provided is different. In this regard, the input services were received by the Appellant in the course or furtherance of its renting an immovable property business. Hence, there is no violation of Rule 9 of CENVAT Credit Rules, 2004. Thus, the appellant is eligible for the credit availed by them on the basis of the said invoices and hence the impugned order dialling the Cenvat credit on the above ground is set aside. Reversal of Cenvat credit - disallowance on the ground that service tax was not paid by M/s Sonu Services under RCM - HELD THAT:- The stand of the department is not sustainable. Once service tax is paid and the appellant has received it proper invoice evidencing payment of the tax, CENVAT credit is available whether service tax is paid by service provider or recipient. Levy of penalties - HELD THAT:- It is found that penalties have been imposed as the appellant has not paid service tax on certain services. Also, some Cenvat credit availed by the appellant has been disallowed as irregular. In view of the above findings, the demand of service tax has not sustained and the same has been set aside. The Cenvat credit availed has also been held as eligible. Thus, no penalty imposable on the appellant as the demands have been set aside. Appeal disposed off.