AI TextQuick Glance (AI)Headnote
GST goods detention tax-and-penalty payment under protest: final speaking order still required; MOV-09 directed, appeal allowed.
Whether payment of tax and penalty pursuant to a notice under s.129(3) CGST Act, 2017, coupled with release of goods under Form GST MOV-05, dispenses with the requirement of a final order by virtue of the deeming conclusion under s.129(5), was answered in the negative. SC held that every show cause notice must culminate in a reasoned, speaking order; s.129(5) only deems cessation of further proceedings and does not amount to waiver or abandonment of the taxpayer's right to contest the levy or appeal under s.107, particularly where objections are filed and payment is under protest. Non-passing of an order undermines natural justice and may offend Art.265. HC order was set aside and the proper officer was directed to issue a final order in Form GST MOV-09 with summary in Form GST DRC-07 after hearing; appeal allowed.
Requirement of proper officer to pass a final order under section 129(3) of CGST Act or deeming fiction under section 129(5) dispenses with such requirement - Though detained goods were released under Form GST MOV-05, final order was not passed - payment of tax and penalty done by the appellant within the time stipulated in the notice u/s 129(3) - HELD THAT:- Evidently, the discharge order merely records that the detained goods and vehicle were released upon payment of the proposed tax and penalty. It makes no mention of any withdrawal of objections or of the conclusion of proceedings initiated under Section 129(3) of the CGST Act, 2017 - It is a well settled principle that every show cause notice must culminate in a final, reasoned order. While Section 129(5) of the CGST Act, 2017 provides that proceedings shall be deemed to be concluded upon payment of tax and penalty, this deeming fiction cannot be interpreted to imply that the assessee has agreed to waive or abandon the right to challenge the levy – a right that is protected by the very enactment itself. The term “conclusion” as used in Section 129(5) merely signifies that no further proceedings for prosecution will be initiated. It does not absolve the responsibility of the proper officer to pass an order concluding the proceedings. Therefore, the proper officer is duty-bound to pass a formal order in Form GST MOV-09 and upload a summary thereof in Form GST DRT 07 as mandated under Rule 142(5) and the Circular dated 13.04.2018, so as to enable the taxpayer to avail the appeal remedy as per law. In the present case, payment was made under protest, and objections had already been filed by the appellant. Once objections are filed, adjudication is not optional, it becomes imperative to pass a speaking order to justify the demand of tax and penalty, to safeguard the right of appeal under Section 107 of the CGST Act, 2017. The language of section 129(3) is categorical in stating that the officer “shall issue a notice… and thereafter, pass an order”. The use of the words “and thereafter” reinforces the mandatory nature of passing a reasoned order, regardless of payment, particularly where protest or dispute is raised. A waiver, as settled, is an abandonment of a right by express terms or by implication. It is an act by which a party elects to abandon his right to pursue a particular remedy with full knowledge of its existence, making the other party to alter his position or legal status. Acquiescence, on the other hand, will imply the conduct of a party, who refrains from taking any action for a long period of time, despite the knowledge of the violation of his right, thereby precluding his future right to agitate the issue, as it would be hit by laches. The principles of natural justice mandate that when a taxpayer submits a response to a show cause notice, the adjudicating authority is required to consider such response and render a reasoned, speaking order. This is not a mere procedural formality, but a substantive safeguard ensuring fairness in quasi- judicial proceedings. The right to appeal under Section 107 of the CGST Act, 2017, is predicated upon the existence of a formal adjudication. An appeal can lie only against an ‘order’, and in the absence of a reasoned order passed under Section 129(3) of the Act, the taxpayer is effectively deprived of the statutory remedy of appeal - Any consequential action including imposition of tax or penalty, would then be unsupported by authority of law, thereby potentially violating Article 265 of the Constitution of India, which prohibits the levy or collection of tax except by authority of law. Thus, taking into account that objections were filed, payment was stated to have been made under protest due to business exigencies, and the appellant seeks to challenge the levy, the proper officer was under a clear statutory obligation to pass a final order under section 129(3) in Form GST MOV-09 and DRC-07. The refusal by the High Court to direct the passing of such an order, has the effect of frustrating the appellant’s statutory right to appeal and is contrary to well established legal principles governing tax adjudication and procedural fairness. The impugned order passed by the High Court is set aside. Respondent No.3 is directed to pass a reasoned final order under section 129(3) of the CGST Act, 2017, in Form GST MOV-09, after granting an opportunity of being heard as mandated under Section 129(4), and upload the summary thereof in Form GST DRC-07 within a period of one month from the date of receipt of a copy of this judgment - Appeal allowed.