AI TextQuick Glance (AI)Headnote
Issues: (i) Whether, in a complaint under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, the accused can be permitted to lead evidence by affidavit and without first filing a written request to step into the witness box under Section 315 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973; (ii) whether the order closing the accused's evidence was sustainable when the prescribed procedure under Section 315 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 had not been followed.
Issue (i): Whether, in a complaint under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, the accused can be permitted to lead evidence by affidavit and without first filing a written request to step into the witness box under Section 315 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973.
Analysis: The statutory scheme permits the complainant to give evidence on affidavit under Section 145 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, but it does not extend the same facility to the accused. The accused may choose to depose as a witness only after waiving the protection under Section 315 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 and making a written request to that effect. The Magistrate could not direct the accused to file an affidavit in lieu of oral evidence, and the procedure adopted was contrary to the governing provisions and the settled law on the point.
Conclusion: The direction permitting the accused to lead evidence by affidavit was impermissible in law and was liable to be interfered with.
Issue (ii): Whether the order closing the accused's evidence was sustainable when the prescribed procedure under Section 315 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 had not been followed.
Analysis: Although the accused had delayed the matter and had sought adjournments, the foundational procedural step required for the accused to depose in his own case had not first been taken in writing. Once the court had not ensured compliance with that mandatory step, closure of evidence on the footing of an invalid procedure could not be sustained. The error called for correction in supervisory jurisdiction, and the matter had to be restored to the proper stage so that the accused, if so advised, could file the required written application and the trial court could then proceed according to law.
Conclusion: The order closing the accused's evidence was quashed, and the matter was remitted to the trial court for fresh consideration from the stage of a written application under Section 315 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973.
Final Conclusion: The impugned orders were set aside to the extent necessary to correct the procedural illegality, and the complaints were sent back to the trial court for continuation of the proceedings in accordance with the prescribed procedure, with costs directed to be paid to the complainant.
Ratio Decidendi: In a prosecution under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, the accused cannot be permitted to tender evidence by affidavit; if the accused desires to depose in his own defence, he must first file a written request under Section 315 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973, and the trial court must proceed only thereafter according to law.
Accused's defence evidence in cheque dishonour cases must follow Section 315 CrPC procedure; affidavit evidence is not enough
In a complaint under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, the accused cannot tender defence evidence by affidavit unless he first files a written request to step into the witness box under Section 315 of the Code of Criminal Procedure. The complainant may rely on affidavit evidence under Section 145 of the Act, but that facility does not extend to the accused. If the mandatory written request is not made, the accused's evidence cannot be closed on the basis of an invalid procedure; the matter must proceed only after compliance with the prescribed step.
Dishonour of Cheque - no reason cited in the application to justify the grant of leave for cross-examination - violation of principles of natural justice - Accused has not replied to these notices, pursuant to which the complaints came to be filed before the Magistrate. Unfortunately, instead of the Magistrate proceeding with these cheque bounce cases, by filing a summary procedure provided under Section 260 of Cr.P.C., the Magistrate recorded the Plea of the Accused, who pleaded to be tried. - Instead of recording a written waiver of his right under Section 315 Cr.P.C., in terms of Clause (a) of the proviso to Sub-Section 1 of Section 315, the Court directly fixed the matter on 07.10.2024, supposedly for the Accused to file an affidavit in evidence. There are two serious flaws which the learned Magistrate committed at this stage. HELD THAT:- The Magistrate has acted with material irregularities whilst allowing for the above procedure which is contrary to the provision of Section 145 of the Negotiable Instruments Act and to the aforementioned case law. The correct course that ought to have been adopted by the Magistrate at this stage was for the Magistrate to direct the Accused, if he desired to examine himself, to place on record his request in writing for such examination. On such a request being placed on record, the Trial Court ought to have considered the application, and if the Accused was permitted to lead his evidence, and if he sought production of any documents, he would have to make out a case for such documents to be allowed in evidence, subject to the rules of evidence. The application would be subject to dealing with such objections as may be raised by the Complainant. Instead of taking the above course, the Magistrate thereafter allowed for three adjournments on 07.10.2024, 08.11.2024 and 06.12.2024 on which dates the Accused remained absent. These dates were given for the Accused to lead his evidence, and ultimately on 06.12.2024, when the Accused once again sought time, stating that he had to travel out of Goa for business, his application was rejected and his evidence was closed. In Soni Anilkumar Prahladbhai v. State of Gujarat, [2022 (6) TMI 1482 - GUJARAT HIGH COURT], the High Court of Gujarat, whilst deciding on whether the Trial Court was justified in refusing to accept the examination in chief of the accused which was recorded without the accused having submitted a written request to be examined as a witness under Section 315 Cr.P.C., held that 'Admittedly, no written request made to the concerned court as envisaged in Section 315 of the Cr.P.C. Keeping in mind this peculiar and distinguishing fact and the mandate of Section 315 of the Cr.P.C., in my considered opinion, both the courts below have committed no mistake in not accepting the examination-in-chief of the present petitioner.' There is no doubt, that if the application of the Accused under Section 315 was in fact given in writing, and the Accused had sought adjournments on the three dates referred above, the Magistrate would have been fully justified in closing the evidence. There has been a gross delay on the part of the Accused in leading his own evidence and such an order, considering the delay of almost six months since the recording of the 313 Statement till the evidence was closed was well justified. The Accused, if he so desires, shall file a written application placing on record his desire to act as a witness in his own case in terms of Clause (a) of the proviso to Sub-Section 1 of Section 315 Cr.P.C. After this application is filed, the Magistrate shall permit the Accused to lead his oral evidence by personally stepping into the witness box and deposing in the matter. The Accused shall not be permitted to produce any documentary evidence unless he justifies the production of such evidence and specifically applies for the same during the course of his evidence - The Magistrate shall also take into consideration the fact that no reply was filed to the notice under Section 138 issued by the Complainant prior to instituting the complaint. After evidence of the Accused is completed, if the Accused seeks to lead further evidence through any witness, the Magistrate shall not grant the same mechanically but shall consider, on an application filed by the Accused to that effect, shall decide the necessity of examining such witnesses after considering the defence raised by the Accused during the cross examination of the Complainant. The impugned orders dated 06.12.2024 are quashed and set aside. The case shall stand relegated to the stage where the Accused shall file his statement/application under Section 315 in the manner stated above. The Magistrate shall then proceed to record the evidence of the Accused and follow the procedure referred - petition allowed by way of remand.