AI TextQuick Glance (AI)Headnote
Corporate guarantor proceedings may follow the principal borrower's insolvency forum, while direct debt and default independently support insolvency initiation.
Corporate guarantor status may arise where a loan agreement and hypothecation deed, read together, establish an undertaking to discharge the borrower's liability on default. Under section 126 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872, the document's title and the absence of all parties' signatures on one instrument are not decisive. Section 60 of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code permits proceedings involving a corporate guarantor before the forum handling the principal borrower's insolvency, notwithstanding the guarantor's registered office elsewhere. Section 7 separately governs insolvency initiation based on the corporate debtor's own financial debt and default; unpaid direct loans and unstayed arbitral awards recording defaults support that independent basis.
Corporate guarantee under loan and hypothecation documents - Territorial jurisdiction over corporate guarantors in CIRP - Financial debt and default under direct loan agreements Corporate guarantee under loan and hypothecation documents - Corporate-guarantor status of a hypothecator assuming joint and several repayment liability and an obligation to meet shortfalls under interlinked loan and hypothecation documents - HELD THAT: - The substance of the covenants, rather than the document's nomenclature, determines whether a guarantee exists. A guarantee may be recorded in several agreements; all parties need not sign a single instrument. Read together, the loan agreement and hypothecation deed made the corporate debtor jointly and severally liable as an obligor and required repayment shortfalls to be met from any source. The deed adopted the obligations under the loan agreement, evidencing a tripartite arrangement between borrower, creditor and surety. The principles in China Development Bank v. Doha Bank QPSC [2024 (12) TMI 1152 - SUPREME COURT] and Punjab National Bank v. Shri Vikram Cotton Mills applied [1969 (9) TMI 68 - SUPREME COURT]. [Paras 27, 28, 34, 35, 36] The corporate debtor was a corporate guarantor within Section 5(5A) of the IBC, and its liability was not confined to the hypothecated assets. Territorial jurisdiction over corporate guarantors in CIRP - Jurisdiction over corporate guarantors registered in Mumbai when the principal borrower's CIRP was pending before the New Delhi Bench - HELD THAT: - The non-obstante clause in Section 60(2) creates an exception to the registered-office rule in Section 60(1). Where the principal borrower's CIRP is pending before a tribunal, insolvency proceedings against its corporate guarantor must be brought before the same tribunal, avoiding conflicting orders and double realisation. The principal borrower's CIRP was pending before the New Delhi Bench, and its admission had attained finality up to the Supreme Court. [Paras 32] The New Delhi Bench had jurisdiction under Section 60(2), notwithstanding the corporate guarantors' registered offices in Mumbai. Financial debt and default under direct loan agreements - Independent justification for admission under Section 7 arising from undisputed direct borrowings and non-repayment - HELD THAT: - Independently of its guarantee liability, the corporate debtor was liable for loans directly advanced to it. Execution of the loan agreements, disbursal and failure to repay were not denied. The defaults had crystallised in arbitral awards, and the challenges to those awards had resulted in no stay. Once the Adjudicating Authority is satisfied that financial debt and default exist, the Section 7 petition must be admitted. [Paras 30, 37, 38, 39] The direct financial debt and default independently warranted admission under Section 7, and the appeals were held not maintainable on that ground alone. Final Conclusion: The appeals were dismissed, leaving undisturbed the common order admitting the corporate debtors to CIRP. Pending applications were also disposed of.