Conflicting interpretations of "interchangeable" in tariff classification required referral to a Larger Bench for resolution.

Conflicting Tribunal views on the meaning of "interchangeable" in Heading 82.05 created a material classification dispute concerning press tool dies. The Bench found tension between earlier decisions and the later view in Bajaj Auto Ltd., and held that the inconsistency required authoritative resolution rather than final determination of classification at that stage. The proper course was reference to a Larger Bench for reconciliation of the competing legal propositions. The order therefore did not decide the tariff classification on the merits and placed the matter before the President for constitution of a Larger Bench.

---

---

Issues: Whether the conflicting views on the meaning of "interchangeable" in Heading 82.05 required reference of the classification dispute concerning press tool dies to a Larger Bench.

Analysis: The rival tariff entries led to conflicting Tribunal decisions on whether press tool dies are interchangeable tools under Heading 82.05 or parts suitable for use with machine tools under the competing headings. The earlier line of decisions and the later view in Bajaj Auto Ltd. were found to be in tension, and the inconsistency was considered material enough to require authoritative resolution. The Bench declined to finally determine the classification itself and instead focused on the need to reconcile the competing propositions of law.

Conclusion: The conflict on the meaning of "interchangeable" was held to require decision by a Larger Bench, and the matter was referred accordingly.

Final Conclusion: No final determination on the tariff classification was returned by this order; the dispute was placed before the President for constitution of a Larger Bench.

Ratio Decidendi: Where authoritative Tribunal decisions disclose a material conflict on the legal meaning of a tariff expression central to classification, the proper course is reference to a Larger Bench for resolution.

---