Prima facie case for waiver of pre-deposit on GTA service tax disputes over inward and outward transportation.

Unconditional waiver of pre-deposit was granted where the assessee showed a strong prima facie case against service tax and penalty on GTA services used for inward and outward transportation. For inward freight on FOR destination supplies, the supplier could not be treated as the assessee's agent, so liability was not established at the stay stage. For outward freight, the dispute was covered by Tribunal precedent supporting the assessee. On that basis, the conditional pre-deposit was waived and stay was allowed.

---

---

Issues: Whether the appellants had made out a prima facie case for unconditional waiver of pre-deposit of service tax and penalty on GTA services used for inward and outward transportation.

Analysis: The appellants were manufacturing metal containers and using GTA services for inward transportation of raw materials and outward transportation of final products. For inward transportation, the supplies were on FOR destination basis, and the supplier could not be treated as the appellant's agent; the liability, if any, was therefore not established against the appellants at the stay stage. For outward transportation, the dispute was covered by precedent of the Tribunal, supporting the appellants' claim. In these circumstances, the appellants established a strong prima facie case for waiver of pre-deposit.

Conclusion: The conditional pre-deposit was waived and stay was granted unconditionally in favour of the appellants.

---