TaxTMI Login
Just a moment...
Press 'Enter' to add multiple search terms. Rules for Better Search
Use comma for multiple locations.
---------------- For section wise search only -----------------
Accuracy Level ~ 90%
of 
Press 'Enter' after typing page number.
of Press 'Enter' after typing page number.
No Folders have been created
Are you sure you want to delete "My most important" ?
NOTE:
of Press 'Enter' after typing page number.
of Press 'Enter' after typing page number.
All Case Laws
of Press 'Enter' after typing page number.
of Press 'Enter' after typing page number.
All Case Laws
Join Channel
Note
Bookmark
Share
Don't have an account? Register Here
of Press 'Enter' after typing page number.
Issues: (i) whether payments made for supply of computer software under the agreements were royalty taxable in India and liable to deduction of tax at source; (ii) whether the foreign supplier had a permanent establishment in India and whether profits from software receipts were attributable to such permanent establishment; and (iii) whether credit of tax deducted at source and levy of interest were to be granted or sustained.
Issue (i): whether payments made for supply of computer software under the agreements were royalty taxable in India and liable to deduction of tax at source.
Analysis: The agreements conferred only a limited licence to use the software, while ownership, copyright, and other intellectual property rights remained with the supplier. The user was prohibited from sublicensing, decompiling, reverse engineering, modifying, or otherwise exploiting the software beyond internal use. The software was treated as a copyrighted work and the consideration was examined under the domestic royalty provision and the India-USA treaty definition of royalties. Applying the distinction between a copyright and a copyrighted article as understood in the treaty context, the software licences were held to involve consideration for the use of, or right to use, copyright in the software.
Conclusion: The payment for software was held to be royalty and taxable in India, and the payer was required to deduct tax at source.
Issue (ii): whether the foreign supplier had a permanent establishment in India and whether profits from software receipts were attributable to such permanent establishment.
Analysis: The record did not show that the foreign supplier had a fixed place, service, or agency establishment in India for the relevant years. The Indian group entity acted under separate contractual arrangements and the material on record did not establish authority to conclude contracts on behalf of the foreign supplier or other facts necessary to constitute a permanent establishment. Since the receipts were already held taxable as royalty, attribution of business profits did not arise on those receipts.
Conclusion: No permanent establishment was held to exist in India, and attribution of business profits was not warranted.
Issue (iii): whether credit of tax deducted at source and levy of interest were to be granted or sustained.
Analysis: Credit could not be denied merely because the deductor later obtained a refund, since valid deduction certificates had been issued and the statutory entitlement of the recipient was unaffected. As to interest, the finding on tax deduction and the admitted deduction of tax on payment supported relief on the relevant interest issue, while consequential and pre-mature objections were not entertained.
Conclusion: TDS credit was directed to be granted, interest under section 234B was not sustained, and the remaining interest-related challenge was rejected as consequential.
Final Conclusion: The Revenue's appeals succeeded on the royalty and withholding-tax issue, while the assessee's appeals succeeded only in part on the PE and TDS-credit questions, resulting in a mixed disposition with the software receipts being treated as taxable royalty and no permanent establishment found in India.
Ratio Decidendi: Where a software licence permits only restricted use of software while the copyright and all substantial exploitation rights remain with the supplier, the consideration is for the use of copyright in the software and is taxable as royalty under the applicable treaty and domestic law.
TaxTMI 
