Misfeasance proof requires specific evidence of appropriation or conduct causing loss; absence of such evidence defeats recovery claims.

Whether misfeasance was established by former directors was decided by assessing whether the Official Liquidator proved appropriation or other misconduct causing loss to the company in liquidation. The court treated the burden of proof as resting on the liquidator and evaluated affidavits, receipts, documentary proofs of hypothecation to secured creditors, auction realisations and admissions in cross examination. Because documentary evidence and explanations showed secured creditor possession, receipts and settlements and there was no specific evidence of appropriation or conduct by the respondents causing loss, misfeasance was not proved and the application was dismissed.

---

---

Issues: Whether the Official Liquidator has established misfeasance by the erstwhile directors under Section 543(1) of the Companies Act, 1956, entitling recovery of amounts claimed.

Analysis: The claim rests on alleged non-delivery or shortfall of assets and receipts as per the statement of affairs. Evidentiary material includes the Official Liquidator's affidavit and receipts, and the respondents' affidavit and documentary proofs showing hypothecation of properties to secured creditors (SIDBI and KSFC), receipts of funds, auction realisation, and subsequent settlement of liabilities. Material admissions in cross-examination show stock, cash receipts and possession/auction by secured creditors; there is no specific evidence of appropriation by or other conduct of the respondents demonstrating misfeasance causing loss to the company in liquidation. The pleaded allegations were met with documentary proof and explanations concerning secured creditor actions and realizations.

Conclusion: The Official Liquidator has not proved misfeasance by the respondents under Section 543(1) of the Companies Act, 1956; the application is dismissed and the respondents are not held liable for the claimed amounts.

---