Survey-based disclosure cannot be taxed in a later year without evidence of income arising in that year.

An estimated or survey-based disclosure relating to earlier years cannot be assessed in a later assessment year without material showing understatement of income in the year under appeal. Where no incriminating evidence, undisclosed asset, cash, or bullion is found, the addition cannot be sustained in that year and must be linked to the correct assessment years. On that basis, deletion of the Rs. 35 lakhs addition was upheld and the revenue's challenge failed.

---

---

Issues: Whether the addition of Rs. 35 lakhs, made on the basis of a survey declaration and treated as understatement of income for the relevant assessment year, was sustainable.

Analysis: The addition was found to rest on an estimated discrepancy relating to earlier assessment years and not on any material showing understatement of income in the current assessment year. No incriminating evidence, undisclosed asset, cash, or bullion was found to justify bringing the amount to tax in the year under appeal. Income, if any, had to be assessed in the correct assessment years and could not be clubbed in a later year merely because of a survey disclosure. The deletion by the first appellate authority was therefore consistent with the statutory scheme.

Conclusion: The addition of Rs. 35 lakhs was not sustainable in the assessment year under appeal and the relief was justified, in favour of the assessee.

Final Conclusion: The revenue's challenge to the deletion of the addition failed, and the other grounds were treated as infructuous.

Ratio Decidendi: An estimated or survey-based disclosure relating to earlier years cannot be assessed in a later assessment year absent evidence that the income was earned in that year.

---