Tribunal Modifies Export Turnover Deduction, Rejects Deemed Export Claim for STP Unit Sales u/s 10A.

The Tribunal partly allowed the appeal. It upheld the AO's decision to deduct foreign currency expenditure from export turnover, but directed that this expenditure should also be excluded from total turnover for consistency. The Tribunal instructed the AO to verify the extension for receiving foreign exchange and allow the exclusion if valid. However, it rejected the claim to treat sales to another STP unit as deemed export under Section 10A, affirming that such sales do not qualify for deemed export benefits beyond the provisions of Section 10A.

---

---

Issues Involved:
1. Deduction of expenditure incurred in foreign currency from export turnover.
2. Exclusion of foreign exchange not received in time from export turnover.
3. Treatment of sales to another STP unit as deemed export under Section 10A.

Detailed Analysis:

1. Deduction of Expenditure Incurred in Foreign Currency from Export Turnover:

The assessee, engaged in the distribution of computer systems and development of software, claimed benefits under Section 10A of the IT Act. The AO made adjustments to the export turnover, including deducting expenditure incurred in foreign currency. The assessee argued that such expenditure should not be deducted from export turnover as it was not involved in rendering technical services. Alternatively, the assessee contended that if the expenditure was to be deducted from export turnover, it should also be deducted from total turnover.

The Tribunal noted that the assessee had excluded a portion of the foreign currency expenditure from export turnover in its return, under the presumption of providing technical services outside India. The AO confirmed that the assessee was indeed involved in rendering technical services, as evidenced by business profiles, invoices, and agreements. The Tribunal upheld the AO's action, stating that the expenditure incurred in foreign currency was related to technical services rendered outside India and should not be deducted from export turnover.

However, the Tribunal accepted the alternative argument, directing that the expenditure incurred in foreign currency should also be excluded from the total turnover to maintain consistency in the formula used for computing deductions under Section 10A, similar to the provisions under Section 80HHE.

2. Exclusion of Foreign Exchange Not Received in Time from Export Turnover:

The AO excluded a sum of Rs. 1,38,40,813 from the export turnover on the grounds that the foreign exchange was not received within the stipulated time. The assessee presented a letter from Canara Bank, indicating authorization for extension of the time limit for receiving foreign exchange for bills less than USD 10,000.

The Tribunal directed the AO to verify the claim and allow the exclusion if the conditions were met, thus providing relief to the assessee on this ground.

3. Treatment of Sales to Another STP Unit as Deemed Export under Section 10A:

The assessee claimed that sales to M/s Texas Instruments India Ltd., a registered STP unit, should be treated as deemed export under Section 10A. The AO and CIT(A) did not accept this claim. The assessee argued that under the Exim Policy, such sales are considered deemed exports and should be treated similarly for the purpose of Section 10A.

The Tribunal examined the Exim Policy, which defines deemed exports and provides benefits such as duty drawback and exemption from terminal excise duty. However, it noted that Section 10A specifically addresses the treatment of domestic sales by STP units, allowing certain benefits if domestic sales do not exceed 25% of total sales. The Tribunal concluded that the Exim Policy does not extend deemed export benefits under the IT Act beyond what is provided in Section 10A. Therefore, the Tribunal upheld the lower authorities' decision, rejecting the assessee's claim to treat sales to another STP unit as deemed export.

Conclusion:

The appeal was partly allowed. The Tribunal directed the AO to exclude foreign currency expenditure from total turnover and to verify the claim regarding the receipt of foreign exchange in time. However, the claim to treat sales to another STP unit as deemed export was rejected.

---