Tribunal Upholds 80% Deduction for Telecom Charges under Sec 10A, Clarifies MAT Computation

The Tribunal upheld the decision to reduce 80% of telecommunication charges from both export turnover and total turnover for deduction u/s 10A, rejecting the assessee's argument for a 50% reduction. Additionally, the Tribunal ruled in favor of the assessee regarding the computation of book profit for MAT u/s 115JB, stating that the 90% restriction on deduction u/s 10A does not impact the calculation of book profit. The Tribunal held that tax on book profits should be based on adjusted book profit and not profits calculated under other provisions, ultimately deciding in favor of the assessee.

---

---

Issues Involved:
1. Reduction of telecommunication charges from export turnover for deduction u/s 10A.
2. Computation of book profit u/s 115JB for Minimum Alternate Tax (MAT) considering the restriction of deduction u/s 10A.

Summary:

Issue 1: Reduction of Telecommunication Charges from Export Turnover for Deduction u/s 10A

The assessee contested the reduction of telecommunication charges from the export turnover for the purpose of claiming deduction u/s 10A. The Assessing Officer (AO) excluded Rs. 6,39,040 for AY 2003-04 and Rs. 4,71,309 for AY 2004-05 from the export turnover, which led to a recomputation of the deduction u/s 10A. The assessee argued that only 50% of such expenses should be reduced, but the CIT(A) and Tribunal consistently held that 80% of these expenses should be reduced from both the export turnover and the total turnover for the purpose of claiming deduction u/s 10A. The Tribunal followed its earlier decisions and directed that 80% of the communication expenses be reduced from both the export turnover and the total turnover for the purpose of claiming deduction u/s 10A.

Issue 2: Computation of Book Profit u/s 115JB for MAT Considering the Restriction of Deduction u/s 10A

The assessee argued that the restriction of deduction u/s 10A to 90% of income should not guide the computation of book profits for MAT u/s 115JB. The AO had enhanced the book profit by Rs. 2,27,665 by adding back the expenditure relatable to income u/s 10A. The Tribunal agreed with the assessee, stating that the computation of book profit u/s 115JB should be based on adjusted book profit, not on profits calculated under other provisions of the Act. The Tribunal cited various judgments, including the Special Bench decision in Bhushan Steel & Strips (P) Ltd., which held that tax on book profits u/s 115JB has an overriding effect and should be calculated on adjusted book profit. The Tribunal concluded that the 90% restriction on deduction u/s 10A does not affect the computation of book profit u/s 115JB, and the assessee should not suffer tax on incomes that do not form part of total income. Therefore, the Tribunal decided this issue in favor of the assessee.

---