Charitable trust exemption fails where property is used for mixed secular and discretionary purposes, not exclusively religious or charitable.

Income from property vested in the head of a community was not exempt under section 4(3)(i) of the Indian Income-tax Act, 1922, because the property was not held wholly for religious or charitable purposes. The deeds showed that the property and its income could be used for agricultural, industrial, commercial and social objects, as well as entertainments and discretionary donations, so the purposes were not confined to exemption-qualifying uses. No severable part of the property was shown to be exclusively earmarked for religious or charitable purposes, and the earlier 1894 deed did not assist because identity of property was not established.

---

---

Issues: Whether the income derived from property vested in the head of the community was exempt from income tax under section 4(3)(i) of the Indian Income-tax Act, 1922, on the footing that it was held under trust or other legal obligation wholly for religious or charitable purposes.

Analysis: The income-tax exemption applied only where the property was held wholly for religious or charitable purposes, or where part of the property was set apart exclusively for such purposes and the income could be identified as applied thereto. The deeds relied upon showed that the property and its income were applicable to a range of purposes, including agricultural, industrial, commercial and social objects, as well as entertainments and discretionary donations. Those uses were not confined to religious or charitable purposes, and no part of the property was shown to be exclusively earmarked for such purposes. The earlier deed of 1894 could not assist, as no identity of property was established between that trust and the property then in question.

Conclusion: The income was not exempt under section 4(3)(i) and the assessment was rightly upheld.

Final Conclusion: The exemption claim failed because the trust property was not held wholly, or in identifiable part exclusively, for religious or charitable purposes.

Ratio Decidendi: Income from property is exempt only when the property is held wholly for religious or charitable purposes, or when a severable part is exclusively so held and the income can be identified as applied to those purposes.

---