Income-tax exemption for wakf denied where deed allowed discretionary use for non-charitable objects and private beneficiaries.

A wakf deed was found not to qualify for income-tax exemption because it created both charitable and non-charitable objects and authorised the mutawallis to apply income at their discretion among them. The deed also provided direct benefit to the wakif's poor relations, and only part of the income was earmarked for purposes that could be regarded as charitable. On that basis, the wakf fell outside section 11 of the Income-tax Act, 1961. The first proviso to section 13(1)(c)(ii) could not assist because it applies only where the trust is otherwise covered by section 11. The earlier decision on the same wakf and its later inclusion in the published list under the Muslim Wakfs Act did not change the income-tax position.

---

---

Issues: Whether the wakf was entitled to exemption under section 11 of the Income-tax Act, 1961; and whether section 13(1)(c)(ii), first proviso, could assist the claim for exemption.

Analysis: The wakf deed created several independent objects, including benefits to the wakif's poor relations, religious observances, marriages and burials of poor Mussalmans, and other pious or charitable purposes, while also authorising the mutawallis to apply the entire income in their discretion among the objects stated in the deed. The deed also set apart portions of income for remuneration, taxes, repairs and management expenses, and only a part of the income was earmarked for purposes that could be treated as charitable. The Court held that the existence of discretionary power to apply income to non-charitable objects, together with the direct benefit conferred on the wakif's relations, took the wakf outside the scope of section 11. The earlier decision on the same wakf and the later inclusion of the wakf in the published list under the Muslim Wakfs Act did not alter the position for income-tax purposes. As the trust was not one falling within section 11, the proviso to section 13(1)(c)(ii), which operates only in the case of a trust otherwise covered by section 11, could not be invoked.

Conclusion: The wakf was not entitled to exemption under section 11, and the claim under section 13(1)(c)(ii), first proviso, also failed; both questions were answered against the assessee.

Final Conclusion: The income of the wakf remained taxable because the deed permitted discretionary application of income to objects that were not wholly charitable and the statutory conditions for exemption were not satisfied.

Ratio Decidendi: Where a trust deed confers discretion to apply income to both charitable and non-charitable objects, and any part of the income may validly be used for non-charitable purposes or for direct benefit of specified private beneficiaries, the trust is not a trust wholly or in part for charitable purposes within the exemption provision.

---