Branch transfer is not a sale under the Karnataka Sales Tax Act, so purchase tax reimbursement was unavailable.

Mere branch transfer of finished goods by a manufacturer does not constitute a sale under the Karnataka Sales Tax Act, 1957. The statutory scheme linked reimbursement of purchase tax under section 5A to industrial inputs used in manufacturing goods inside the State for sale, and the goods had to be transferred by way of sale in the course of trade for consideration. Where the finished goods were only consigned or moved to branch offices and not sold to another purchaser, the essential ingredients of sale under section 2(1)(t) were not satisfied. On that basis, reimbursement under section 5A was unavailable.

---

---

Issues: Whether mere stock transfer of finished goods by the manufacturer constituted a "sale" so as to entitle the assessee to reimbursement of purchase tax under section 5A of the Karnataka Sales Tax Act, 1957.

Analysis: The relevant statutory scheme required industrial inputs to be purchased for use in manufacturing goods inside the State for sale, and reimbursement under section 5A was linked to the taxable sale of the finished goods. A sale under section 2(1)(t) involved transfer of property in goods to another person for consideration in the course of trade or business. On the facts found by the authorities, the goods were transferred to the assessee's branches by stock transfer and not sold as goods to another purchaser. Such a transfer did not satisfy the essential ingredients of sale, and therefore did not attract the benefit of reimbursement under section 5A. The binding principle applied was that reimbursement is available only where the manufactured goods are sold and taxed within the State, not where they are merely consigned or transferred to branch offices.

Conclusion: Mere stock transfer is not a sale under the Karnataka Sales Tax Act, 1957, and the assessee was not entitled to reimbursement under section 5A.

Ratio Decidendi: Reimbursement of purchase tax on industrial inputs is available only when the finished goods manufactured inside the State are actually sold for consideration; mere branch transfer or consignment of the manufactured goods is outside the concept of sale.

---