AI TextQuick Glance (AI)Headnote
Issues: (i) Whether additions in unabated/completed assessment years under section 153A are permissible in the absence of incriminating material found during search; (ii) Whether additions for alleged on-money in Nana Chiloda Project and Sumel Business Park-III based on third-party digital material are sustainable; (iii) Whether additions for alleged under-invoicing of sales by extrapolation from material seized from another entity/year are sustainable; (iv) Whether additions for alleged on-money in the Stellar Project based on third-party chats are sustainable; (v) Whether disallowance of exemption under section 10(38) (alleged penny-stock LTCG) in unabated years is sustainable without incriminating material; (vi) Whether addition of Rs.40,00,000 under section 69A/115BBE for alleged on-money in Earth Erita project can be sustained.
Issue (i): Whether additions in unabated/completed assessment years under section 153A are permissible in the absence of incriminating material found during search.
Analysis: The issue concerns the jurisdictional predicate for assessments under section 153A where the assessment year was completed on the date of search. The legal rule as applied requires that additions for such unabated years must be founded on incriminating material unearthed during the search in the case of the particular assessee and for the particular year; reliance on third-party or post-facto material unrelated to the assessee or year does not fulfill the jurisdictional requirement.
Conclusion: This issue is decided in favour of the Assessee.
Issue (ii): Whether additions for alleged on-money in Nana Chiloda Project and Sumel Business Park-III based on third-party digital material are sustainable.
Analysis: The facts involve additions founded on WhatsApp chats and digital notes recovered from third parties, differing survey/shop numbers, and dated after the transactions. The material lacked direct nexus, corroboration, cash trail, or verification and related in many cases to unabated years where no incriminating material was found from the assessee's premises.
Conclusion: Additions based on such third-party digital material are unsustainable; the issue is decided in favour of the Assessee.
Issue (iii): Whether additions for alleged under-invoicing of sales by extrapolation from material seized from another entity/year are sustainable.
Analysis: The AO extrapolated a 4060% suppression ratio from documents seized from a different legal entity and for a different assessment year. There was no incriminating material tied to the assessee for the relevant years, no mandatory rejection of the assessee's books under section 145(3) before estimation, and no corroborative evidence to support group-wide extrapolation.
Conclusion: Extrapolation from another entity/year without independent incriminating material is legally flawed; the issue is decided in favour of the Assessee.
Issue (iv): Whether additions for alleged on-money in the Stellar Project based on third-party chats are sustainable.
Analysis: The impugned additions rested on a third-party WhatsApp chat post-dating the transaction and not connected to the assessee; there was no corroborative cash evidence or nexus to the assessee's transaction.
Conclusion: The additions are unsustainable; the issue is decided in favour of the Assessee.
Issue (v): Whether disallowance of exemption under section 10(38) (alleged penny-stock LTCG) in unabated years is sustainable without incriminating material.
Analysis: The disallowance was based on general investigation reports and third-party statements without specific incriminating material seized from the assessee for the relevant years. The assessee produced documentary evidence (demat statements, contract notes, bank entries, STT payment) which was not effectively rebutted by corroborative incriminating material.
Conclusion: Disallowance in unabated years without incriminating material is unsustainable; the issue is decided in favour of the Assessee.
Issue (vi): Whether addition of Rs.40,00,000 under section 69A/115BBE for alleged on-money in Earth Erita project can be sustained.
Analysis: The AO relied on a higher provisional agreement value and a third-party statement; the assessee provided a plausible explanation of renegotiation, a sworn affidavit from the purchaser denying any cash payment, and there was no cash trail or cross-examination of the purchaser. The addition lacked corroboration and direct incriminating material.
Conclusion: The addition is unsustainable and is deleted; the issue is decided in favour of the Assessee.
Final Conclusion: The Tribunal's findings uniformly apply that, where assessment years were unabated on the date of search, additions under section 153A must be supported by incriminating material found in the search in the assessee's case; absent such material or adequate corroboration, additions based on third-party digital data, extrapolation from other entities/years, or uncorroborated statements are legally unsustainable.
Ratio Decidendi: Additions in completed/unabated assessment years under section 153A are impermissible unless directly based on incriminating material unearthed during the search relating to the specific assessee and assessment year; third-party digital material, uncorroborated extrapolation, or standalone statements do not satisfy this jurisdictional and evidentiary requirement.
Assessment under Section 153A: third-party digital chats and unrelated search material cannot justify additions in unabated years
Assessment under search laws cannot be sustained in unabated or completed assessment years in the absence of incriminating material found from the assessee; accordingly, additions premised solely on a third-party WhatsApp chat are inadmissible and deletable. The revenue bears the onus to prove investments beyond recorded consideration and cannot discharge it by reliance on uncorroborated, unrelated digital communications; hence such chats, post-facto to the transaction and not tying to the specific property, lack evidentiary value and cannot justify additions. Material or modus operandi recovered from a different entity or assessment year cannot be extrapolated to another assessee or year, and deletions of such additions are warranted.
Assessment u/s 153A - Jurisdiction in Unabated Assessments & Addition for Nana Chiloda Project - incriminating material unearthed, seized during the search and post-search operation - AO possessed material in the form of a third-party WhatsApp chat indicating a much higher market rate for properties in the same area. It was argued that the search on the third party was conducted simultaneously Unabated assessments/ no incriminating material unearthed - In the instant case, it is an admitted fact, and was also fairly conceded by the Ld. DR during the course of hearing, that no incriminating document, asset, or any other material was found or seized from the premises of the assessee that could remotely suggest the payment of any consideration over and above what was recorded in the registered sale deed. The AO, in this case has presumed the payment of on-money by relying upon the digital chat recovered from a third person’s mobile phone. Such material, which belongs to a third party and was not found during the search action in the case of the assessee, cannot be construed as "incriminating material" for the purpose of assuming jurisdiction under Section 153A in the hands of the present assessee for an unabated assessment year. The jurisdictional prerequisite, as mandated by the Hon’ble Supreme Court, is conspicuously absent in the facts of the present case. Moreover, the said chat is not relating to the land purchase transaction of the assessee and, hence, the unrelated third-party chat relating to a different property cannot be treated as incriminating material in the case of the assessee. This issue is, accordingly, decided in favour of the Assessee and against the Revenue. Merits—onus, evidence, and character of digital chats - The impugned additions are not sustainable. It is a settled principle of law, enunciated in the case of K.P. Varghese [1981 (9) TMI 1 - SUPREME COURT] that the onus to prove that an assessee has invested more than what is recorded in the books of accounts is squarely and heavily on the Revenue. This onus cannot be discharged by relying on suspicion, surmises, or uncorroborated third-party information. The WhatsApp chat relied upon by the AO is nothing but a "dumb document" which has no evidentiary value whatsoever, against the assessee. It does not name the assessee, it pertains to a different survey number, and it is dated almost a full year after the assessee’s transaction was concluded and registered. AO has made no independent inquiry to verify the contents of the chat, has not cross-examined the parties to the chat to establish its authenticity or context, and has brought no material on record to establish a live and direct nexus between this third-party chat and the specific transaction undertaken by the assessee. The addition is based on assumptions and presumptions, which is impermissible in law. Therefore, looking from any angle, both on the jurisdictional ground as laid down by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in “Abhisar Buildwell” [2023 (4) TMI 1056 - SUPREME COURT] and on the merits of the case, the addition made by the AO is legally untenable and deserves to be deleted. We, therefore, find no infirmity in the well-reasoned order of the Ld. CIT(A) on this issue and in deleting the impugned addition. Addition on account of alleged under-invoicing of sales - Material Unearthed During Search Action - Statements Recorded - A perusal of the assessment order reveals that the AO extrapolated a supposed modus operandi which he believed was unearthed during the search of a different entity, namely M/s Shivali Fashions, and that too for a different assessment year - A.Y. 2020-21. This supposed modus operandi was then blindly applied to the present assessee’s for various unabated assessment years. The law does not sanction such a course of action. The Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Sinhgad Technical Education Society [2017 (8) TMI 1298 - SUPREME COURT] has held that material relating to one assessment year cannot be used to make additions in other assessment years without there being corresponding incriminating material found for those specific years. By the same logic, material found from the premises of one assessee cannot be used against another assessee without an independent basis. The action of the AO is thus legally flawed on two counts: firstly, for making additions in unabated years without any incriminating material found in the assessees’ cases, and secondly, for extrapolating findings from one entity and for a different assessment year to another entity and for a different assessment year. This action of the AO is jurisdictionally flawed and is unsustainable the eyes of law. The Ld. CIT(A) correctly deleted these additions. Addition on account of alleged on-money in the Stellar Project - In the absence of any incriminating material found during the course of search Action, no addition can be made in an unabated/ completed assessment year. The assessment year is unabated. The material relied upon is a third-party WhatsApp chat found from a person unrelated to the assessee. The chat is post-facto to the transaction. No corroborative evidence was found. In view of the law laid down by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of case of Abhisar Buildwell (supra), we hold that the impugned addition is unsustainable legally as well as factually on merits. Disallowance of exemption u/s 10(38) of the Act (Penny Stock) - The Hon’ble Jurisdictional Gujarat High Court in a series of cases, including PCIT vs. Rajesh Mohanbhai Patel [2023 (5) TMI 1355 - GUJARAT HIGH COURT] has consistently held that in the absence of any incriminating material found during the search, additions on account of alleged penny stock transactions in unabated years are not sustainable, especially when the assessee has provided documentary evidence to prove the genuineness of the transactions. In the light of the binding precedents and the facts on record, we hold that the Ld. CIT(A) was fully justified in deleting these additions. The appeals of the Revenue on this issue are accordingly dismissed.