AI TextQuick Glance (AI)Headnote
1. ISSUES PRESENTED AND CONSIDERED
(i) Whether the adjudication order confirming tax, interest and penalty was liable to be set aside and the matter remanded where the show cause notice and reminder were uploaded on the GST portal's "Additional Notices Tab" (prior to portal changes), resulting in no effective notice, no reply, and no personal hearing.
(ii) What remedial directions were required to restore a fair opportunity of participation in adjudication, including timelines, costs, communication mode for hearing notice, and portal access.
(iii) Whether the Court should decide the validity of the challenged notifications extending time limits, or leave that issue open in view of pending consideration before the Supreme Court and a pending lead matter before this Court.
2. ISSUE-WISE DETAILED ANALYSIS
Issue (i): Validity of ex parte adjudication where SCN/reminder were placed in "Additional Notices Tab" leading to absence of reply and hearing
Legal framework (as discussed by the Court): The Court applied the requirement that adjudication should not be concluded "in default" and that the noticee must get a fair opportunity to file a reply and be heard, consistent with principles of natural justice, as reflected in the Court's approach in similar matters.
Interpretation and reasoning: The Court found that the show cause notice (issued in September 2023) and reminder (issued in November 2023) were uploaded on the "Additional Notices Tab" on the GST portal at a time when that tab was not suitably visible (changes being made only after January 2024). On these facts, the Court accepted that the notices did not appear to have come to the petitioner's knowledge, leading to non-filing of reply and non-attendance at personal hearing, and consequently an ex parte adjudication with adverse demand. In such circumstances, the Court held that the petitioner did not receive a proper opportunity to be heard and therefore the matter warranted remand for adjudication afresh after participation.
Conclusion: The Court set aside the impugned adjudication order and remanded the matter to the adjudicating authority, specifically because the petitioner had no effective notice and consequently no meaningful opportunity to reply or be heard.
Issue (ii): Scope of remand and directions to ensure effective opportunity
Legal framework (as discussed by the Court): The Court proceeded on ensuring procedural fairness through a renewed opportunity to submit a reply and attend personal hearing, and requiring a "fresh reasoned order".
Interpretation and reasoning: To cure the defect of ineffective portal communication and absence of hearing, the Court prescribed a structured opportunity: (a) time to file reply to the show cause notice; (b) a condition of costs; (c) an obligation on the adjudicating authority to issue a personal hearing notice and communicate it through specified electronic means; (d) a requirement to consider the reply and hearing submissions and pass a reasoned order; and (e) ensuring portal access so the reply and documents can be accessed and uploaded.
Conclusion: The Court granted time up to 31 January 2026 to file the reply, subject to payment of costs of Rs. 10,000/- to be deposited by 10 January 2026; directed that after the reply, a personal hearing notice be issued and communicated to the petitioner via the stated e-mail and mobile contact; directed a fresh reasoned order after considering submissions; and directed that GST portal access be provided within one week to enable uploading and access to notices/documents.
Issue (iii): Adjudication of the validity of the challenged notifications
Legal framework (as discussed by the Court): The Court noted that the validity of the relevant notifications was under consideration before the Supreme Court, and that certain matters concerning parallel State notifications were being considered in a separate lead matter before this Court.
Interpretation and reasoning: Given the pending consideration of the notification-validity questions at higher and coordinate levels, and because the present case could be disposed of on the narrower ground of lack of effective opportunity to respond and be heard, the Court declined to finally decide the notification challenge in this petition.
Conclusion: The Court expressly left open the issue of validity of the impugned notifications. It further directed that any fresh adjudication order would remain subject to the outcome of the Supreme Court proceedings concerning the relevant notification issues and the pending lead matter before this Court, while keeping all rights and remedies of the parties open.
GST show-cause notice uploaded only in hidden "Additional Notices" portal tab; demand order set aside, case remanded.
The dominant issue was whether adjudication based on a SCN uploaded only in the GST portal's "Additional Notices" tab, before that tab was made visible, violated natural justice. Relying on prior HC decisions holding that such portal-only uploading could deprive a taxpayer of effective notice and hearing, the Court found the petitioner had not received a proper opportunity to respond, as no reply had been filed to the SCN. Consequently, the impugned demand order was set aside and the matter remanded to the adjudicating authority, granting time to file a reply by a specified date subject to payment of costs.
Challenge to SCN and impugned order - vires of N/N. 09/2023- Central Tax dated 31st March, 2023 and N/N. 09/2023- State Tax dated 22nd June, 2023 - extension of time limit for adjudication of SCN - HELD THAT:- This Court in NEELGIRI MACHINERY THROUGH ITS PROPRIETOR MR. ANIL KUMAR VERSUS COMMISSIONER DELHI GOODS AND SERVICE TAX AND OTHERS [2025 (3) TMI 1308 - DELHI HIGH COURT] under similar circumstances where the SCN was uploaded on the ‘Additional Notices Tab’ had remanded the matter holding that 'The impugned demand orders dated 23rd April, 2024 and 5th December, 2023 are accordingly set aside. In response to show cause notices dated 04th December, 2023 and 23th September, 2023, the Petitioner shall file its replies within thirty days. The hearing notices shall now not be merely uploaded on the portal but shall also be e-mailed to the Petitioner and upon the hearing notice being received, the Petitioner would appear before the Department and make its submissions.' Moreover, this Court in SUGANDHA ENTERPRISES THROUGH ITS PROPRIETOR DEVENDER KUMAR SINGH VERSUS COMMISSIONER OF DGST & ORS. [2025 (5) TMI 234 - DELHI HIGH COURT] under similar circumstances where no reply was filed to the SCN had remanded the matter holding that 'This Court is of the opinion that since the Petitioner has not been afforded an opportunity to be heard and the said SCN and the consequent impugned order have been passed without hearing the Petitioner, an opportunity ought to be afforded to the Petitioner to contest the matter on merits.' There is no doubt that after 16th January, 2024, changes have been made to the GST portal and the ‘Additional Notices Tab’ has been made visible. However, in the present case, the impugned SCN was issued on 27th September, 2023 and subsequent reminder was issued on 10th November, 2023, which is prior to 16th January, 2024. The same does not appear to have come to the notice of the Petitioner. Under such circumstances, considering the fact that the Petitioner did not get a proper opportunity to be heard and no reply to the impugned SCN has been filed by the Petitioner, the matter deserves to be remanded back to the concerned Adjudicating Authority. The impugned order is set aside. The Petitioner is granted time till 31st January, 2026, to file the reply to impugned SCN, subject to payment of Rs.10,000/- as costs to be deposited with the Sales Tax Bar Association by 10th January, 2026 - Petition disposed off by way of remand.