AI TextQuick Glance (AI)Headnote
Issues: (i) Whether refusal to permit cross-examination of the person who retrieved the electronic data vitiated the final assessment orders on the ground of violation of natural justice; (ii) Whether the proper officer could resort to best judgment assessment while proceeding under section 74 of the CGST Act, 2017.
Issue (i): Whether refusal to permit cross-examination of the person who retrieved the electronic data vitiated the final assessment orders on the ground of violation of natural justice.
Analysis: The request for cross-examination was directed against the author of the data retrieval report on which the assessment was substantially based. A litigant is not required to challenge every intermediate order separately, and a ground of natural justice can be raised against the final order if the earlier rejection was not tested on merits. The right to cross-examine is part of natural justice, but it is not automatic; the assessee must show a specific need and prejudice. On the facts, the data was retrieved in the assessees' presence, the process was certified by them, and their own statements admitted that the data had been entered by them. The request was therefore too broad and no prejudice was shown.
Conclusion: The refusal to permit cross-examination did not vitiate the assessment orders, and this issue is decided against the assessees.
Issue (ii): Whether the proper officer could resort to best judgment assessment while proceeding under section 74 of the CGST Act, 2017.
Analysis: Best judgment assessment is expressly provided only in the statutory settings covered by sections 62 and 63 of the CGST Act, 2017, with the corresponding rule. Section 74 does not confer any such power. The omission is treated as deliberate, and in tax matters the assessing authority cannot travel beyond the method authorised by statute. Levy and collection of tax must be by authority of law under article 265 of the Constitution of India, and an implied best judgment power cannot be read into section 74. Rule 31 was irrelevant to the issue. The impugned assessments were therefore made without jurisdiction to the extent they proceeded on extrapolation and best judgment.
Conclusion: The proper officer could not resort to best judgment assessment under section 74 of the CGST Act, 2017, and this issue is decided in favour of the assessees.
Final Conclusion: The assessments founded on best judgment extrapolation under section 74 were unsustainable and were quashed, with the writ petitions consequently allowed.
Ratio Decidendi: In the absence of an express statutory provision, a taxing authority cannot adopt best judgment assessment or extrapolation while acting under a provision that only authorises determination on the material available under the statute; denial of cross-examination causes no vitiation unless prejudice is shown.
Best judgment assessment under GST section 74 impermissible absent express statutory power; denial of cross-examination caused no prejudice.
Denial of cross-examination of the person who retrieved electronic data did not vitiate the assessment because the data was obtained in the assessees' presence, certified by them, and no specific prejudice was shown. In contrast, best judgment assessment could not be imported into proceedings under section 74 of the CGST Act, 2017, because such power is expressly provided only in sections 62 and 63 and cannot be implied where the statute does not authorise it. The court held that tax must be levied only by authority of law under article 265, found the extrapolated assessments without jurisdiction to that extent, and quashed them.
Principles of natural justice - right to cross-examine - reliance on third party electronic data retrieval - best judgment assessment - statutory basis for assessment u/s 74 of the CGST Act, 2017 - statutory provisions authorising assessment (Sections 62 and 63; Rule 100(2)) - extrapolation of sales data - constitutional requirement for taxation under Article 265 - HELD THAT:- It is not in dispute that the assessment order relies on the report of the staff of M/s.FDI Labs, Chennai who retrieved the data from the electronic devices seized during the search operation. The technical rules of evidence may not be applicable as such to assessment proceedings. But when the report which forms the basis of the order itself is questioned, the proper officer is obliged to make available the author of the report for cross-examination. Failure to do so may render the assessment order vulnerable for having breached the principles of natural justice provided that the assessee is able to show prejudice on account of such denial. It is well settled that though the right to cross examine a given witness may not be provided by or under the statute, it being a part of the principles of natural justice should be held to be an indefeasible right. But the assessee must still make out a case for cross examination. It will not be “Ask, and it shall be given”. The assessee seeking cross-examination ought to give specific reasons why cross-examination is needed in a particular situation and that too of specific witnesses. A blanket request to cross-examine all persons whose statements have been recorded by the department, cannot be sustained (Vallabh Textiles v. Addl. Commissioner, Central Tax [2025 (4) TMI 1154 - DELHI HIGH COURT] (GST). Applying the above principle, the petitioners may not have a case for cross-examining the author of the report containing the data recovered from the electronic devices of the assessees. This is because, the assessees had nowhere questioned the veracity of the data retrieved from the systems maintained by them. It is seen that the retrieval took place very much in their presence. The assessees themselves duly certified the process of retrieval. While the retriever who was only a technical person might not have been competent to describe the nature of the data retrieved from the systems as “actual sales data”, that may not really make much of a difference. The assessees were examined and their statements were recorded under Section 70 of the Act. To specific questions, they admitted that the data retrieved from the systems was actually entered by them. Therefore, hold that the request to cross-examine the retriever of data was rightly denied and in any case, it did not cause any prejudice to the petitioners. Best judgment assessment - statutory basis for assessment under Section 74 of the CGST Act, 2017 - It is not the case of the proper officer that the impugned orders against the writ petitioners have been passed by invoking either Sections 62 or 63 of the Act. It is obvious and plain that those provisions are inapplicable to the case on hand. The impugned orders have been passed under Section 74 of the Act. But in Section 74, not able to find any provision conferring the power on the proper officer to assess the tax liability of the noticee or the assessee to the best of his judgment. Section 74(9) of the Act states that the proper officer shall after considering the representation, if any, made by the person chargeable with tax, determine the amount of tax, interest and penalty due from such person and issue an order. There has to be a statutory basis for any action to be taken by the assessing officer. The enabling power must flow from the statute. Only mystics can materialise objects from thin air. The proper officer is not endowed with such powers. Article 265 of the Constitution not only talks about levy of tax but also collection of tax. Levy as well as collection can be done only by the authority of law. The constitutional mandate is therefore that what is not envisaged by law directly cannot be done indirectly in the matter of tax collection. The Hon'ble Full Bench of the Madras High Court in the PS. Subramaniam Chettiar & Sons vs. Joint Commercial Tax Officer III, Dindigul [1966 (8) TMI 50 - MADRAS HIGH COURT], while considering the unamended Section 16 of the Madras General Sales Tax Act, 1959, held that there is no room for holding that there is an implied power to assess by best judgment when the Section does not expressly provide for the same. Therefore, uphold the contention of Shri. S. Jaikumar, the assessees that while passing an order under under Section 74 of the CGST Act, 2017, the proper officer cannot resort to best judgment assessment. To reiterate, without an express statutory provision empowering the proper or assessing officer to resort to best judgment assessment, the authority would not have the jurisdiction to do so. Thus, the orders impugned in these writ petitions stand quashed.