Refund claim of excess duty paid - valuation of Physician's...

Refund claim of excess duty paid - valuation of Physician's sample - The assessable value, as indicated in the 2002 circular, is 115% of the cost of production. The Tribunal having come to this conclusion, in our opinion ought not to have taken recourse to the 2003 circular which adverts to the CAS-4 methodology - matter remanded back to ascertain cost of production - HC