Set-off of joint venture loss denied where the venture is a separate taxable entity from the assessee-company.

A company cannot set off a loss arising from a joint venture against its own other income unless the loss belongs to the same assessee. The joint venture was treated as a separate income-tax entity, either an unregistered firm or, alternatively, an association of persons, so its loss could not be transferred to the company for set-off. The fact that the venture was systematic and trade-like did not change the identity of the taxable entity or extend the computation rules applicable to one assessee to a different legal person.

---

---

Issues: Whether the assessee-company was entitled to set off its share of loss arising from a joint venture against its other income.

Analysis: The joint venture was found to be a distinct income-tax entity from the assessee-company, being either an unregistered firm or, alternatively, an association of persons. The right of set-off under the Income-tax Act depended on the loss belonging to the same assessee and not to a different taxable entity. The rules applicable to computation of business income of one assessee could not be extended to a loss incurred in a separate venture carried on by different legal persons. The fact that the venture was systematic and trade-like did not alter the identity of the assessee for purposes of set-off.

Conclusion: The assessee-company was not entitled to set off the loss of Rs. 11,875 against its other income.

---