Dummy unit doctrine requires consistent central excise assessment and can justify remand for fresh adjudication.

Where an adjudicating authority finds that several units are only shadow or dummy concerns of one manufacturing entity for central excise purposes, duty and related liabilities must be assessed consistently on that basis. An inconsistent confirmation that treats each unit as independently liable cannot be sustained, and fresh adjudication with adequate opportunity to the parties is required when the factual matrix is materially the same as an earlier remand situation.

---

---

Issues: Whether the demand of duty and penalties could stand where the adjudicating authority recorded that only one unit was the manufacturer and the remaining units were shadow or dummy units, and whether the matter required remand for fresh adjudication.

Analysis: The order recorded a finding that the four units were to be treated as a single entity for central excise purposes, but the demand had been confirmed in a manner that effectively treated each unit as independently liable. Where the adjudicating authority accepts that there is only one real manufacturing entity, the duty demand must be worked out consistently against that entity, and the liability of the others cannot be sustained on the same footing. The factual pattern was treated as materially identical to the earlier Supreme Court remand decision relied upon by the appellants. In these circumstances, fresh consideration by the Commissioner was necessary after giving the parties adequate opportunity to place their case.

Conclusion: The appeals were allowed, the impugned order was set aside, and the matters were remanded to the Commissioner for fresh decision.

Ratio Decidendi: Where an adjudicating authority finds that multiple units are merely shadow or dummy concerns of a single manufacturing entity, the demand and related liabilities must be determined consistently on that basis, and an inconsistent confirmation against all units warrants remand for fresh adjudication.

---