Product classification and pre-deposit principles: alcodegrease dispute turned on competing tariff headings and absence of hardship proof.

Classification of "alcodegrease" turned on whether it was a pickling preparation under sub-heading 3810.00 or a cleaning preparation under sub-heading 3402.90. The Tribunal noted that pickling preparations are ordinarily acid-based, while degreasing preparations are ordinarily alkaline, and found no expert material from the applicants to rebut the departmental view. On the pre-deposit question, it treated Ballarpur Industries as the governing precedent pending the Larger Bench reference in Cot Spun Ltd. and held that financial hardship had not been shown. Deposit was directed as a condition for hearing, with stay and waiver of the balance on compliance.

---

---

Issues: Whether the product "alcodegrease" was classifiable as pickling preparations under sub-heading 3810.00 or as cleaning preparations under sub-heading 3402.90; and whether, pending the appeal, a pre-deposit should be ordered with stay and waiver of the balance.

Analysis: The Tribunal compared the competing headings and noted that pickling preparations are ordinarily acid-based, while degreasing preparations are ordinarily alkaline though either may vary. It also noted the absence of any expert material from the applicants to counter the departmental opinion. On the separate question of re-classification and past demand, the Tribunal treated the three-member decision in Ballarpur Industries as the governing view pending the Larger Bench reference in Cot Spun Ltd., and considered that financial hardship had not been shown.

Outcome: The applicants were directed to deposit Rs. 30,000/- as a condition for hearing of the appeals, with stay and waiver of the balance upon deposit, and the matter was listed for reporting compliance.

---