Consumer packing justified confiscation, but bona fide research and development use warranted remission of penalty and lower redemption fine.

Imported goods brought in consumer packing and fit for immediate use were liable to confiscation, because that form of import brought them within the category justifying seizure on merits. However, the importer's bona fide explanation that the goods were intended for research and development was accepted as a mitigating factor. On that basis, the penalty was remitted and the redemption fine was reduced, while confiscation itself was sustained.

---

---

Issues: (i) whether confiscation of the imported goods was sustainable on merits, and (ii) whether the redemption fine and penalty required reduction in view of the circumstances of import.

Issue (i): whether confiscation of the imported goods was sustainable on merits.

Analysis: The goods were imported in consumer packing, ready for use by consumers after mixing with water. Though the importer claimed bona fide import for research and development use and not as a mass consumer item, the form of import brought the goods within the category justifying confiscation.

Conclusion: Confiscation on merits was upheld.

Issue (ii): whether the redemption fine and penalty required reduction in view of the circumstances of import.

Analysis: The goods were not comparable to ordinary items of mass consumption fetching high profit. The explanation that the import was for research and development purposes was accepted as a mitigating factor, warranting leniency in the quantum of monetary consequences.

Conclusion: The penalty was remitted and the redemption fine was reduced to Rs. 4 lakhs.

Final Conclusion: The order of confiscation was sustained, but the monetary burden was substantially reduced by remitting the penalty and cutting down the redemption fine.

Ratio Decidendi: Where imported goods are brought in consumer packing fit for immediate use, confiscation may be sustained, but bona fide circumstances can justify reduction of redemption fine and remission of penalty.

---