Specific tariff classification for unexposed cinematograph film prevailed over residuary headings for jumbo-roll imports.

Cinematograph film imported in jumbo rolls was treated as retaining the essential character of unexposed cinematograph film despite requiring slitting and perforation before use. The specific tariff entry for cinematograph films unexposed was held to govern classification, and the residuary entries for other photographic films or goods were rejected as inapplicable. Tariff headings were read according to their ordinary scope, while the HSN explanatory notes were treated as persuasive only. The earlier Tribunal view on the same goods was followed, and the contrary distinction based on another cited decision was not accepted.

---

---

Issues: Whether cinematograph film (unexposed) imported in jumbo rolls was classifiable for customs additional duty under the specific tariff entry for cinematograph films unexposed or under the residuary entries for other photographic films or goods.

Analysis: The imported goods were held to retain the essential character of cinematograph films notwithstanding that they required slitting and perforation before use. The tariff description for cinematograph films unexposed was treated as specific and controlling, while the residuary entries were held inapplicable. The scheme of classification was determined primarily from the tariff headings and their ordinary scope, and the explanatory notes to the HSN were treated as merely persuasive. The earlier Tribunal view on the same goods was followed, and the distinction sought to be drawn from the other cited decision was rejected as inapposite.

Conclusion: The goods were correctly classifiable under the specific entry for cinematograph films unexposed and not under the residuary headings.

Final Conclusion: The appeal failed on the classification issue and the lower appellate order was sustained.

---