Agricultural income treatment for sale of old rubber trees upheld where removal formed part of plantation replantation.

Receipts from the sale of old and unproductive rubber trees uprooted during replantation in a continuously cultivated plantation are agricultural income, because the character of the receipt depends on ongoing agricultural operations on the land. The sale was incidental to plantation agriculture and, being derived from trees removed as part of cultivation and maintenance, fell within section 2(1A) and was exempt under section 10(1). The fact that the assessee also carried on timber business did not alter the character of the receipt arising from its own agricultural operations, and authorities based on wild or spontaneously grown trees were held inapposite. The addition was therefore unsustainable.

---

---

Issues: Whether the receipt arising from sale of old and unproductive rubber trees uprooted from a cultivated plantation in the course of replantation is agricultural income under section 2(1A) of the Income-tax Act, 1961 and exempt under section 10(1), or taxable as business income or capital receipt.

Analysis: Agricultural income under section 2(1A) depends on the carrying on of agricultural operations on land, not on whether the assessee originally planted the trees. Where the plantation is under continuous cultivation and maintenance, felling of senile trees and replantation form an integral incident of plantation agriculture. The receipt from sale of such trees, when they are part of a cultivated plantation and are removed in the course of replantation, is incidental to agricultural operations. The authorities below relied on cases concerning wild or spontaneously grown trees, which are materially different because they lack the element of human skill, labour, and cultivation. The mere fact that the assessee also carries on timber business does not change the character of the receipt arising from agricultural operations on its own land.

Conclusion: The receipt of Rs. 27,00,000 from sale of old and unproductive rubber trees is agricultural income under section 2(1A) and is exempt under section 10(1); the addition is unsustainable.

Ratio Decidendi: In plantation agriculture, receipts from sale of old trees removed as part of cultivation and replantation are agricultural income where the plantation is maintained through continuous human agricultural operations.

---