Classification of colour television parts turns on actual goods cleared, not deemed complete sets under tariff interpretative rules.

Classification of colour television parts must be determined first by the heading terms and relevant section or chapter notes; interpretative Rule 2(a) applies only when all critical components of the complete article are presented together. Because the consignments did not contain all essential components of a complete CTV at the same time and the goods were cleared as parts and sub-assemblies, Rule 2(a) was inapplicable. Heading 85.29 therefore governed the goods actually cleared, and the demand of duty, interest and penalty could not be sustained.

---

---

Issues: Whether the parts and sub-assemblies of colour television sets cleared without all critical components were classifiable as complete television sets under Rule 2(a) of the Schedule to the Central Excise Tariff Act, 1985, or as parts under Heading 85.29, and whether the demand of duty, interest and penalty could therefore be sustained.

Analysis: The governing principle is that classification must first be determined from the heading terms and the relevant section and chapter notes, and only if that exercise does not resolve the issue can the interpretative rules be invoked. On the facts, the clear finding was that the consignments cleared by the assessee did not contain all the critical components of a complete television set at the same time. The components were supplied in different consignments and the essential parts necessary to constitute a complete CTV were not removed together. In that situation, Rule 2(a) had no application. The relevant section note also required parts falling within the specified chapters to be classified in their respective headings, and Heading 85.29 was held to be the specific heading for the goods actually cleared.

Conclusion: The goods were not classifiable as complete colour television sets under Rule 2(a) and were correctly classifiable as parts under Heading 85.29. The demand of duty, interest and penalty was unsustainable and the assessee succeeded.

Ratio Decidendi: Rule 2(a) of the tariff interpretation rules applies only when all components of the complete article are presented or removed together at the same time; where the goods are merely parts or sub-assemblies lacking the critical components, classification must be governed first by the relevant heading and section note, and not by deeming the goods to be complete finished goods.

---