Hotel-project licence rights taxed as short-term capital gains; transfer was not treated as business income or trading adventure.

Rights under a hotel-project licence deed were treated as a capital asset when assigned for consideration, and the transfer was taxed as short-term capital gains because the rights were held only from the 1981 licence deed, not from an earlier inchoate claim. The licence created only a permission to use, not an interest in immovable property, so registration was not required on that footing. The receipt was not treated as business income or an adventure in the nature of trade, as there was no dominant profit-making intention in the assessee's acquisition and transfer of the licence rights. Ancillary items were partly remanded, partly sustained, and partly allowed.

---

---

Issues: (i) Whether the sum of Rs. 1 crore received on transfer of the hotel-project licence was business income arising from an adventure in the nature of trade; (ii) whether the same receipt was chargeable as capital gains on transfer of a short-term capital asset, and whether the licence required registration or was held from 1977 so as to be a long-term asset.

Issue (i): Whether the sum of Rs. 1 crore received on transfer of the hotel-project licence was business income arising from an adventure in the nature of trade.

Analysis: The transaction was found to be one of acquiring a licence for a five-star hotel project and thereafter transferring the licence rights to a newly formed company. The assessee itself never intended to run the hotel business as a trading venture, and the materials did not show a dominant profit-making intention in the sense required for an adventure in the nature of trade. The fact that the assessee had earlier negotiated for the project and had taken steps for the project did not convert the transaction into trading activity.

Conclusion: The receipt was not business income and was not assessable as income from an adventure in the nature of trade, in favour of the assessee.

Issue (ii): Whether the same receipt was chargeable as capital gains on transfer of a short-term capital asset, and whether the licence required registration or was held from 1977 so as to be a long-term asset.

Analysis: The rights transferred under the agreement of 18 June 1981 were the rights arising out of the licence deed dated 11 March 1981, not an earlier inchoate right from 1977. Those rights constituted a capital asset within the wide meaning of section 2(47) of the Income-tax Act, 1961, and the transfer was completed when the assessee assigned those rights to Bharat Hotels Ltd. The licence deed created only a licence and not an interest in immovable property, so registration was not required on that footing. The asset was held only from 11 March 1981 and therefore was not a long-term capital asset. The cost of acquisition was not nil, since the assessee had incurred expenditure, including earnest money-related outlay, litigation expenses and other project costs, in acquiring the rights.

Conclusion: The receipt was taxable as short-term capital gains and the licence was not a long-term capital asset, in favour of Revenue.

Issue (iii): Whether the ancillary grounds relating to unclaimed balances, entertainment expenses, directors' remuneration, telephone expenses, car expenses and pooja expenses were to be sustained, reduced or remanded.

Analysis: The unclaimed balances and entertainment expenses required fresh examination on the factual material; the disallowance relating to directors' remuneration was substantially upheld, while the computation of directors' perquisites was modified; the car-disallowance was sustained; and part of the pooja-related expenditure was held allowable as revenue expenditure.

Conclusion: These grounds were disposed of partly by remand, partly by confirmation and partly in favour of the assessee.

Final Conclusion: The principal receipt was held not to be business income but taxable as short-term capital gains, while some ancillary additions were remanded or reduced, resulting in a partly allowed disposal of the cross-appeals.

Ratio Decidendi: Rights arising under a licence deed can constitute a capital asset, and when those rights are assigned for consideration the transfer is taxable as capital gains according to the actual period for which that licence right is held; a mere licence, unlike an interest in immovable property, does not require registration on the footing of section 17(1)(b) of the Registration Act, 1908.

---